That's great and so nice to get that reaction from them. I really want to surprise my family like that sometime. I don't know when or what, but I'm determined to do it.
It was fun! And very worth it. Surprising with a deluxe is a great one to pull off. But what about water park tix? or a tour?
I can relate. The best we got was a free brownie sundae on my birthday in MK and a free chocolate ice cream "because the machine was about to run out anyway". Oh well, you take what you can get. But a room upgrade is obviously at the top of the list.
Free is free, and I'd not turn down a free anything. Except maybe a colonoscopy. (which reminds me....) But yeah, I'd agree, a room upgrade is WAY up there! Can't get much better than that except for maybe free dining for the duration of your trip.
I get it. Although I don't have a hater, DW is not quite as Disney as me. She enjoys it and looks forward to it, but doesn't have that extra "something" most of us DISers have. Just last week I was helping her plan (ie: doing it for her) her and DD's dance school trip in July. I had her scheduled for a full day at DHS, but she said she didn't know if she wanted a full day, since DD does not do roller coasters and neither of them are into Star Wars. I said that I assumed she would want to see Fantasmic in the night. She asked "have they changed it? I've seen it three times". So yeah, not a hater, but not quite a DISer.
Helping her plan....

I've heard (and done) that one before.
"I'm going on a trip to Alaska with my dad, can you help me plan it?"
Translation: "I'm going on a trip to Alaska with my dad, please find us some RV parks, check flight prices, what tours there are..."
Now, regarding DHS- you know what? We stopped this last trip and watched the Streetmosphere skits for a LONG time (sorry, TR spoiler there) and had a BALL!! They are SO funny! I think I could spend a day there and do ok. FAR from my favorite park, but still plenty to do. One Man's dream, watching the Imperial March, having lunch at Prime Time or Sci-Fi, Streetmosphere....
Snack time all the time at Disney. I like that. I have the feeling that if I ever do pay to stay concierge, I may in fact get my money's worth just at the snack bar alone.
You know what, after this trip and getting a taste of Concierge, I can see myself at some point in the future getting the Concierge package at AKL, completely foregoing park tickets altogether and just doing a resort vacation. LOADS of pool time, CL Lounge time, room time, verandah time, you know....never leave.
I need to show my wife these pictures. She's convinced that if we stay at AKL, there will be lions climbing up the balcony trying to get in the room. And the place will smell like manure.
We never ever smelled anything "bad" once. There is a pretty wide barrier between the resort building and the animal enclosure, so even if you were to drop something, there'd be 20 or 30 feet between yu and them.
That's fantastic on both fronts! Adventure is out there!
Indeed!