Who are these people? Actually I could probably guess the exact broker.
You really shouldn't have a huge problem getting a 200pt BLT contract at $160, but it depends on how much time you have to wait if they aren't budging. From what I've seen in the past few months that is a more than fair offer on that type of contract that should pass ROFR. The thing is though at those prices they tend to go in a couple days; many on the market now at $170-$179 have been there for months. BLT is one of the resorts I'm considering and have seen many pop up at nice prices but my issue has been use year
It's so weird because I've never had an issue getting them to drop below asking. Maybe it's the broker. My last 3 offers were $10-$13 under asking and they were all accepted without counter (unfortunately for me though, right after each one Disney decided to go on a purchasing frenzy and ROFR'd prices that normally wouldn't have for both contracts I tried to push through).
I'm not in a rush to book and use points though due to the timing of my next trip.