DH and I ate here for the first time in February 2005 during his first night at WDW and we thought it was magical. He loved it so much that we went back for lunch on our last day!!
Fast forward to August/September 2005 - went with mom, stepfather, DH and I... And it was decidedly meh. Average service, average food, above average prices. We still enjoyed it because of our "magic hangover" from the previous visits, but no more than that.
Finally, Candlelight Processional Package in December 2005 - food tasted better if you could get over the fact that it was STONE COLD

, and our table was rickety, with a waiter who didn't give much of a you-know-what about the fact that salsa was spilling over our table every time someone passed by (because of how close together the tables were).
We haven't been back since.
That being said, I'm hoping to go back this November, just to see whether the magic is well and truly dead. I LOVE real mexican food and SAI has a special place in my heart from our first trip together. Here's hoping it will be back up to its usual standard...
