I agree with someone upthread who said that coordinating trips with large groups will be much more difficult now. I'm planning a large group trip in April where people aren't even staying at the same hotel, much less the same rooms. When we've done this in the past, we got together *at home* to map out what we were going to book and could easily get 90% of what we wanted. I'm not even sure how that will work now, or what we'll do if some in the group don't want to pay but others do.
----
Now that I've slept on it, I think I've figured out what bothers me most. I don't mind paying more. Ticket prices go up every year and the idea of paid FPs had been floating around for a while. What I really don't like is the nickel-and-dime vs. all-inclusive vibe.
DCL has always argued that their prices are higher because they include everything -- soda station, shows, characters, private island, etc. It gives a more exclusive, and relaxing, feel to the cruise. The whole cruise industry is like that, with the higher end lines including everything. That was the same feel in WDW if you stayed on site or with DVC.
Disney, and specifically vacationing through DVC ownership in Disney, has always had that same pricey-but-inclusive vibe. It meant sometimes extensive preplanning for vacations but then relaxed non-commando vacations because everything was done ahead of time. DVCers by definition are people who prefer to preplan vacations and avoid some of the typical stress of vacations. They also travel with extended parties often.
This move to a la carte pricing by Disney is a complete 180 from the inclusive vibe they'd build up over decades and IMO cheapens the product. From a DVC perspective where you go much more frequently and plan more curated trips, an a la carte model with only day-of booking options is the opposite of what many DVCers want.
I really don't get it. It's hard to build up the kind of reputation that Disney had of being 'more than a theme park' and it took decades to build it up. Every step they've taken this year has chipped away at that reputation and made WDW more like most other theme parks (which IMO other theme parks do better, including DL).
WDW is a destination and was structured as such. Now, with it lowering itself to theme park status? I think they are going to find out that a lot of people can get a better and less expensive theme park experience someplace else. I'm not paying what I pay for DVC to get up every morning to try to grab experiences, paying as I go like I would have to on a cheap cruise. I don't want to try to coordinate every morning with friends and family staying onsite. I don't want those kind of hassles for the money I'm paying.
I really don't understand why they would willingly give up their reputation of being more exclusive and providing an elevated experience by adopting a cheaper a la carte pricing model on everything. I'm not upset about the increased cost so much but the feeling like I woke up this morning owning a cheaper product than I did yesterday. Much cheaper.