American Idol Thread

[minniecarousel]

My observations:

David C. was amazing (again)

Brooke is starting to look like a "one-trick pony". Don't get me wrong - I love her voice and her type of singing, but she has that foksie slant to all her songs. Maybe not a bad thing.

KLC gets "most improved singer". She still isn't my favorite.

Syesha amazes me in that I can't figure out how she is still in this competition.

 

[corie161]

Any other Brooke fans? Man I just love her. David C is still my #1, but I so enjoy Brooke's voice. I'm not usually a fan of chick singers, Norah Jones being the exception. I worry that Brooke will go before KLC (God that girl bores me to death)

I really like Brooke too. I'm praying that she can hang on, I'd rather see Syesha go before Brooke and then Kristy. I don't think either of these is horrible, just don't really have any pizzazz. Brooke has a uniqueness to her voice and seems sincere when singing.

 

[jacksonsmom]

I love David Cook! he is great. I would buy his CD in a heartbeat. I don't find David Cook "Hot" but there is something about him that makes him cute and attractive

The performances:

David A --- Eh, forgettable

Brooke --- I like Brooke, but she didn't do that good. I think she may be in the bottom three

Carly --- OK, but I totally understand what the judges were trying to tell her

Kristy Lee --- Eh, forgettable

Seyesha --- Eh, forgettable

Jason --- Good! I like his mellow singing voice. He just seem like a really great guy to hang out with at a coffee shop

David Cook ---- AMAZING!!!! I love, love, love him!!!!

Who are the bottom three:
Brooke
Seyesha
Kristy Lee Cook

I won't care if Seyesha or Kristy Lee go home, but I hope Brooke stays for a little bit longer

 

[sassyat30]

Wowser! That studio version is terrific!

I think his version is 100 times better than the original.

 

[Robinrs]

I love David Cook! he is great. I would buy his CD in a heartbeat. I don't find David Cook "Hot" but there is something about him that makes him cute and attractive

The performances:

David A --- Eh, forgettable

Brooke --- I like Brooke, but she didn't do that good. I think she may be in the bottom three

Carly --- OK, but I totally understand what the judges were trying to tell her

Kristy Lee --- Eh, forgettable

Seyesha --- Eh, forgettable

Jason --- Good! I like his mellow singing voice. He just seem like a really great guy to hang out with at a coffee shop

David Cook ---- AMAZING!!!! I love, love, love him!!!!

Who are the bottom three:
Brooke
Seyesha
Kristy Lee Cook

I won't care if Seyesha or Kristy Lee go home, but I hope Brooke stays for a little bit longer

Sooooo agree!!!

Here's David's performance from last night...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVAs2zmb0ig

 

[TanyaLovesPooh]

David Cook was awesome!

I think Brooke is the one going home.

 

[damo]

David Cook was awesome!

I think Brooke is the one going home.

I think they will divide the three guys into one group (who will be safe), three girls into the other (bottom three) and then have the final girl guess what group she is in. Not sure who that safe girl is going to be though. My guess is Brooke or Kristy.

 

[happygirl]

I think Brooke is the one going home.

I really hope she stays

 

[dturner]

David Cook was awesome!

I think Brooke is the one going home.

I do too - she just fell apart last night and at this point in the competition that's not good.

 

[Robinrs]

I really hope she stays

Of all the girls Brooke is my favorite... I hope she stays, too.

 

[happygirl]

Looks like Vote for the worst is bragging that they got rid of Michael Johns last week, I really hate vote for the worst

 

[wdwgirl03]

I really like Brooke too. I'm praying that she can hang on, I'd rather see Syesha go before Brooke and then Kristy. I don't think either of these is horrible, just don't really have any pizzazz. Brooke has a uniqueness to her voice and seems sincere when singing.

Count me in as another Brooke fan!! She's by far my favorite girl contestant.

I swear if Kristy does not go home tonight... I am getting so annoyed with her it's not even funny! UGH.

 

[Robinrs]

Looks like Vote for the worst is bragging that they got rid of Michael Johns last week, I really hate vote for the worst

VFTW has NO power, they are just pitiful people who take pleasure in being vindictive and evil. Their so called "power" didn't work for Danny or Amanda and when it didn't they stomped around like demons who just got holy water thrown at them...

Everyone except one person is leaving eventually, I guess they'll take credit for all of them, huh?

 

[Philagoofy]

Without You was made famous by Harry Nilsson long before Mariah Carey recorded it. How is it "her" song?

 

[lizardqueen]

I really hope that Kristy or Syesha go home tonight.

 

[Figment22]

Without You was made famous by Harry Nilsson long before Mariah Carey recorded it. How is it "her" song?

I'm glad they let it be considered "her" song because it was the only song I recognized last night! (Well, Hero was vaguely familiar too.)

 

[bicker]

Think about the phrase that is continually used on AI: "Make it your own." And Mariah Carey is definitely one who makes practically anything she sings "her own".

 

[Robinrs]

Without You was made famous by Harry Nilsson long before Mariah Carey recorded it. How is it "her" song?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Without_You

Rockin' Robin was a hit in 1956 and some people think only Michael Jackson sung it! I'm sure the author didn't mind the residuals he got from Mariah's version...

 

[Acklander]

I'm stuck at work tonight without a TV, any update postings would be MUCH appreciated!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Thanks!

 

[disneynutt1225]

The Davids, Carly and Jason are all safe.