I was born and raised in FL. I know all of the "rules" you're supposed to follow when around any body of water(the saying is "If there is water, there are gators."). I wouldn't have been thinking about gators if it were me and my children out there. My kid wouldn't be in the water, not because of gators, but because of the brain eating bacteria. I think it's pretty rare for this gator to come out and just grab a kid. The area seemed pretty open and there were people there. Gators are usually pretty skittish.
In just a handful of comments on this thread there are such wide disparities in what people understand about no swimming signs and gator behavior, yet some people were so quick to point fingers at the father because surely he should have had the complete picture they did and is negligent for not preventing the tragedy.
I agree.
I've been visiting Florida my entire life, & I'm aware of the bacteria, alligators, & snakes. But, just from the different comments on this thread, I can easily see where people who are not familiar w/ Florida & its wildlife would NOT be aware of the various dangers.
We've stayed at Fort Wilderness, the Wilderness Lodge, & the Contemporary several times, & we were always on the lookout for alligators. We were told one lived around the dock at the Wilderness Lodge, &, whenever we were on the dock, we'd occasionally look for him.
However, while I know about alligators, I've never been all that concerned. My primary concern & my reason for keeping my kids out of the water has always been the bacteria - not the alligators.
One night, at Fort Wilderness, our kids played on the beach - not in the water or really all that near the water, but, still, I guess within striking distance if an alligator had decided to come up on land.
I would have thought that the beach would have been too noisy/crowded during the movie & fireworks time, & that any alligators would be far away from the noise.
Also "no swimming" means different things to different people. Some people interpret it to mean "no lifeguard on duty." Some people think it means literally no swimming w/ your whole body in the water - but wading is fine.
Regarding the bacteria, our 2 older kids & I got stuck on Splash Mountain once at the top in the sun. The ride was stopped for over an hour, & the castmembers kept coming to check on us & bring us water. (The guys in "suits" even came out.) Our log was within stepping distance of the deck walkway - we could step out of the log, put one foot in the water, & then step up onto the walkway. But they wouldn't let us. When I asked, one castmember told me, "Oh no! You wouldn't want to step in the water. It's filthy." Oookay... I understand that. But, isn't that the same water that gets splashed in our faces as we come down the hill?
Again, our family is aware of the bacteria & other things like alligators lurking in the water, so we stay out of the water. But I could definitely see how a family not as familiar w/ the area could see the "no swimming" sign differently & would not know to be cautious.
I can see Disney changing some of their signage, but I hope they don't put up fences around all the waterways.
My thoughts & prayers are w/ the family. I can't even imagine how horrifying it would have been & how heartbroken they are today.