I don't like to stay onsite so I'm glad we aren't planning another trip for 2 years so I will get a good chance to see how this all shakes out.
Ditto this. Or at least, I keep telling myself I'm glad we're not going for a while because everything's so up in the air.
It is gonna be visually very obvious that I am staying offsite because I won't be wearing a magic band.
I never even thought of that! But I think spiceycat is right that it would be a publicity debacle, and Disney hates negative press. Which also hadn't occurred to me.
Thanks for pointing that out,
spiceycat!
Once they completely roll it out, I think they will offer it to all guests but I do think there will be some perk to being onsite, either more FP+ selections or the ability to choose them earlier (like 180 + 10 for onsiters).
My thoughts exactly.
I have read that offsite guests may be able to purchase Magicband/FP+ which I am not thrilled about, but I understand that Disney needs to keep developing ways to make staying on their property as attractive as possible.
This seems likely, since I believe that's how Universal works it -- you can get their Express pass either by staying onsite or by paying extra for it.
instead of just the rides - it will also include shows, fireworks, and parades.
This is actually the part that most concerns me. Well, and the fact that so many more attractions are part of it. Whether offsite people can get one or not, I think the bands may really change the crowd balance. People are much more likely to go to the "slower" attractions if they've signed up for them, and I think the choices newbies make at home will be very different from the choices they'd make wandering the parks. Fastpasses do slow down the standby line, and how much they slow it down can be unpredictable.
Right now I have pretty much instant access to a lot of the slower things I love if we go offseason; if people start signing up for them because they can't get what they really want, then the crowds will be more evenly spread and it'll be harder to find those pockets of peacefulness. I can totally understand why Disney would want to do that, but it makes the parks a lot less attractive to me.
OTOH, we've been wanting to do the Harry Potter stuff at Universal since before it first went in; if the Disney parks look iffy in 2015 due to the bands, maybe that'll be enough of a boost to get us there.