Originally posted by PamOKW
Now that we know the points required, does Concierge still seem like a good idea to most folks? It is an option but is it one that makes sense to use? (58-146 points at GF).
No way. You can ALMOST get a grand villa at BWV for what it costs to stay at GF concierge. It doesn't even specify that those concierge rooms are even MAIN building concierge... they may be the limited concierge rooms in Sugar Loaf Key... in either case, we did stay in the GF Royal Palm Club main building concierge and it was wonderful and worth every penny we paid for a once in a lifetime vacation.
That said, for the same points as 1 week in a GF concierge room I could have 2 weeks in a 2BR at BWV or 3 weeks in a 1BR at BWV or 5 weeks + 6 days in a studio that is almost the same size as that concierge room at the GF and I know which
I'd choose (i'm basing these numbers on value season points where a week in GF concierge is 498 points, 2 weeks in a 2BR is 444 points, 3 weeks in a 1BR is 486 points and 6 weeks in a studio minus 1 weekend day is 490 points.)
If i were that intent on blowing around 500 points on one week i'd just splurge on the extra 60 points and get a grand villa and bring 11 of my closest friends to share it with me. Even the biggest GF fans would be hard pressed to be able to compare a grand villa at the BWV with a standard sized room with concierge servce at the GF... the room at the GF even with concierge service only rents for around 1/3 the cash price of the grand villa.
Somehow since joining
DVC, the amenities of concierge aren't nearly as appealing to me... I don't need to go to a lounge to get snacks, I can go to my own fridge to get them. Sure, I may not be able to book the chef's table at victoria and alberts on a moment's notice, but on the other hand I enjoy planning my WDW vacations so much that I have all of my things planned way before I get there.
While I loved the GF for our honeymoon and looking forward to staying there again some day, even paying $600/night to stay there in concierge (if I decided it was worth it) seems like a bargain compared to the $1200+ in accomodations I'd be giving up to stay there on points.
Lisa