I think ONE person has said something about writing "lazy bride." Hardly a hoard.I'm not really bothered by it. In the day and age of most brides and grooms working full time, I would think it would be appreciated.
I always think it's a bit odd that those who most vehemently claim how TACKY it is and anybody who knows proper etiquette would know this are the ones who have said they'd write lazy *** bride in the return address or write a note on the envelope giving their disapproval!
I'd bet almost anything that etiquette experts would say that is far worse than the original faux pas.
Etiquette aside, it's just rude and nasty behavior. I mean really putting a bride "in her place" for something that in all likelihood somebody else planned on what's supposed to be a happy day? That's just ugly and petty.
If you're so stringent on having things done your way, maybe you shouldn't attend gatherings for others. Especially since wedding traditions and etiquette vary widely both regionally and culturally. What white Anglo-Saxon experts say is not the be-all end-all of wedding etiquette in the U.S., let alone anywhere else.
And all this blather about saving the bride so much time. It takes 20-30 seconds for her to address an envelope and her guests have already spent hours on her shower, between shopping, travel and attendance. A few seconds hardly seems a burden. As for not having addresses... If you know them well enough to solicit a gift, I'd think you know where they live or work. If not, the hostesses could make the effort to get that info. I've hosted many showers and have always managed to give the bride/mother to be a guest list with addresses at the end.
I don't care if the bride has a job and is busy. So are her guests. If it is too much work for the bride to address the envelopes, the hostesses should do it for her. You can have a raffle with just names on a piece of paper, without an address. (Although I applaud the skill shown at using a game to pass along the bride's job to her guests.)
It boils down to this. Whose job should it be? The gift giver, who has already done their part? Or the gift recipient, who would have to spend perhaps two minutes per guest thanking them? To me, the answer is plain.