Saying grace...

chobie said:
Glad to be of service. Merry Christmas.

Happy Holidays. I just think that you come across as holding your defensive shield so front and center that some of your comments are extreme, which then makes other points that you make possibly lose credibility with others because they've already dismissed you. You can say that you don't give a flip though; you won't offend me. :)
 
SwedishMeatball said:
Happy Holidays. I just think that you come across as holding your defensive shield so front and center that some of your comments are extreme, which then makes other points that you make possibly lose credibility with others because they've already dismissed you. You can say that you don't give a flip though; you won't offend me. :)

Credibility is as crediblity does. That is the way with these boards. We all have posters we admire and will agree with just about every thing they say and we all have posters that we completely dismiss for whatever reasons. You can't please everyone.

I think you are trying to be kind to me right now, though, and if you are I do appreciate it. :goodvibes
 
And you are well aware that many of people with your belief system are not so respectful of others. And it is disprectful to put your non-believieng house guests in an uncomfortable position of having to sit thru a ritual grace-saying.

Yes, and those that aren't make my life a LOT more difficult as I'm sure those with your belief system who disrespect others do for you.

If it's my house, and my regular mealtime ritual is to say grace-I'm saying it. If I know someone doesn't believe, I will tell them when I invite them that grace is the practice in my home. That way they can choose to accept the invitation or not. I've never had anyone refuse or walk to the restroom during the 30 seconds that I take to say grace. My friends and family who don't believe seem to be able to handle that 30 seconds without it ruining their day. When I visit at their homes, I say my own grace silently and without making the sign of the cross or even closing my eyes. I think God understands that I'm trying to respect their choice. I doubt anyone would even know I'm doing it. I do the same when I'm eating out. (although I'm rethinking that-why should I be ashamed to show my faith?)
 
I was raised that prayer was a private thing outside of Church. We only said grace at my Meme's house and that was essentially a moment of silence with the sign of the cross.

Saying grace is a huge bone of contention between myself and my in-laws. They like to hold hands and pray loudly in restaurants. It makes me extremely uncomfortable and yet I used to participate because it was polite. Not anymore - not since MIL took issue with me making the sign of the cross. I did it a few times after she gave me a dirty look (in Latin just to mess with her) and then she continued so I figured if you don't let me pray how I feel comfortable praying in an uncomfortable situation then I'm not going to be the only one compromising so I don't do it at all.

So I'll stand and bow my head but I do not hold hands and pray.
 

chobie said:
Credibility is as crediblity does. That is the way with these boards. We all have posters we admire and will agree with just about every thing they say and we all have posters that we completely dismiss for whatever reasons. You can't please everyone.

I think you are trying to be kind to me right now, though, and if you are I do appreciate it. :goodvibes

True, but there are also people on these boards that I don't agree with on a lot of things, but I openly listen to their opinions and don't want to be closed off from really hearing what they have to say.

Until you said "Merry Christmas", I had forgotten about that thread. I'm not holding a grudge and I hope you're not, but I can't control it if you are.
 
SwedishMeatball said:
True, but there are also people on these boards that I don't agree with on a lot of things, but I openly listen to their opinions and don't want to be closed off from really hearing what they have to say.

Until you said "Merry Christmas", I had forgotten about that thread. I'm not holding a grudge and I hope you're not, but I can't control it if you are.


No not a grudge. More of an inside joke.
 
Fitswimmer said:
Yes, and those that aren't make my life a LOT more difficult as I'm sure those with your belief system who disrespect others do for you.

If it's my house, and my regular mealtime ritual is to say grace-I'm saying it. If I know someone doesn't believe, I will tell them when I invite them that grace is the practice in my home. That way they can choose to accept the invitation or not. I've never had anyone refuse or walk to the restroom during the 30 seconds that I take to say grace. My friends and family who don't believe seem to be able to handle that 30 seconds without it ruining their day. When I visit at their homes, I say my own grace silently and without making the sign of the cross or even closing my eyes. I think God understands that I'm trying to respect their choice. I doubt anyone would even know I'm doing it. I do the same when I'm eating out. (although I'm rethinking that-why should I be ashamed to show my faith?)

Again you should not be ashamed of your faith. Who ever said that?
 
/
chobie said:
Again you should not be ashamed of your faith. Who ever said that?

Nobody did, I didn't mean to give that impression. It's my own hangup because I was concerned about offending anyone with any outward expression. The thinking that I've done while reading this thread has made it clearer to me that it was my own problem.
 
Fitswimmer said:
Nobody did, I didn't mean to give that impression. It's my own hangup because I was concerned about offending anyone with any outward expression. The thinking that I've done while reading this thread has made it clearer to me that it was my own problem.

Agreed. If people are offended then its their problem. But I feel that way about a lot of things and others have disagreed with me. Some people could make the claim that if your public praying is done loud enough for them to hear at their table then you are infringing on them and it is their business.
 
chobie said:
Agreed. If people are offended then its their problem. But I feel that way about a lot of things and others have disagreed with me. Some people could make the claim that if your public praying is done loud enough for them to hear at their table then you are infringing on them and it is their business.

I don't say anything loud enough to be heard unless you were right next to me. The only thing anyone at another table might see is the sign of the cross if they were looking at the exact right 5 seconds that it takes to do that. That's why I know I'm really being silly by not doing it. Nobody is that interested in what I'm doing and it's pretty egotistical of me to think they are.
 
Okay, folks, this has really gotten out of hand.

Allow me to clarify further:

I was not trying to stir any pot with this post, at least not intentionally. It seems a lot of people have jumped to some conclusions thinking I am attacking their religious beliefs. That simply isn't true. I don't have a problem with any of you believing in whatever you believe in, really I don't. The issue at hand is one of bringing it into my home when you know how I feel about it.

I never said I would rudely get up from the table and walk away at someone else's home. If these were people who were not aware of my feelings, yes, I would sit quietly, but not participate. If questioned on this, I would quietly say I don't believe in it. That usually settles things without incident. If that's not acceptable to the host and they choose to make an issue of it, I would thank them for the invitation, tell them I do not wish to make them uncomfortable, and leave if they wish. That has never happened.

In almost every situation, the family or friends are fully aware of my feelings and understand that I will join them once they get grace out of the way. I usually go wash my hands, as much in preparation for eating as anything else. It's my way of giving them the opportunity to do what they want without feeling awkward about me sitting or standing there. On occasion, one or two family members have insisted they wait for me even after being told I do not do grace or prayers. This was just them being the idiots they are because those particular people aren't even religious.

Quite often I do not want to accept invitations for these dinners and that is for a number of reasons I won't bore you with. Infortunately, I have my wife to consider and she comes from a big family (I don't).

I also stated that if they need to pray before they eat in my home, I have no problem if they do so to themselves and not expect me to join in. Unfortunately, some people feel God isn't paying attention unless they make a little show of it. That, in my home, I have a problem with. I don't have much say in who my wife invites, but they all know how I feel about religion. To insist that they openly say grace anyhow, is rude, and a number of you have agreed with that. When I said they should take their prayer outside or all the way home was more out of frustration than what I would actually do. Perhaps I was wrong in expressing myself that way.

I have found that many, not all, but many Christians can be judgemental and many replies on this thread have proven that. Many are also very nice people and consider me their friend even if I am a heathen. They respect my beliefs and stay out of my face with theirs, even though I am open to friendly discussion about the entire issue. I include among those friends a priest, a bishop, and several ministers. Even though we are at odds regarding religion, we remain friends because we respect each other as people. As one might expect, their answers to my issue aren't as objective as I would like, so I reached out to the DIS members for some ideas.

When I started this post I was simply looking for some objective input on how to properly handle the issue of people wanting to say grace in my home. It bothers me that I have created a format for some pretty heavy bickering and that certainly was not my intention. I had hoped for a handfull of replies in which I might find a viable solution for my problem.

As for weddings and funerals (and I'll add christenings), I do not, as a rule, attend church service weddings, funerals, or christenings and while my friends my not like that, they understand. On the rare occasion I must attend a wedding (daughter or son, someday grandchildren) I keep a low profile and do not pretend to be a Christian for the moment. For funerals, I do not attend the church portion and quietly refrain from prayer at graveside. For christenings, I absolutely do not believe in the practice and do not attend, ever, even for my own children and grandchildren. That used to shock a lot of people, but they have come to deal with it.

Regarding the friends who asked me to be godfather to their son, I was, indeed, flattered and did politely decline. I just found it totally out of character for devout Christians to make such a request to someone they knew to be a devout heathen. I guess I tend to look for logic in too many things. By the way, that friendship dwindled because they could not carry on a simple conversation without reference to "the lord." Believe what you want, but please, stay out of my face with it.

I would ask all of you to know that heathens, athiests, and agnostics are people, too. We're not evil and we usually lead good lives. We don't go out trying to recruit members for there is no membership. It's simply what we do or don't believe in in our daily lives. We are as patriotic as anyone and are as willing to help someone in need as anyone. No religion on earth has the market on goodness. It comes in all shapes and sizes... and beliefs. Please accept us for what we are. After all, isn't that the Christian thing to do?
 
chobie said:
I must be, because I know the mere presence of my children in certain restaurants is enough to get other people judging me, but I don't care. I bring them anyway.

And we all know how that never ever bothers you when people comment on bad kids in restaurants!!! :rotfl:

I think if I ever wanted to find you, I'd just start up a thread about some bad kids that were sitting at a table beside me in a restaurant and voila! There you'd be!

I'm really just giving you a hard time, because in all truthfulness I just don't think you are very self aware concerning how you would want to be treated. Are you sure you can take it as well as you can dish it out? ;)
 
GeorgeG said:
Okay, folks, this has really gotten out of hand.

Allow me to clarify further:

I was not trying to stir any pot with this post, at least not intentionally. It seems a lot of people have jumped to some conclusions thinking I am attacking their religious beliefs. That simply isn't true. I don't have a problem with any of you believing in whatever you believe in, really I don't. The issue at hand is one of bringing it into my home when you know how I feel about it.

I never said I would rudely get up from the table and walk away at someone else's home. If these were people who were not aware of my feelings, yes, I would sit quietly, but not participate. If questioned on this, I would quietly say I don't believe in it. That usually settles things without incident. If that's not acceptable to the host and they choose to make an issue of it, I would thank them for the invitation, tell them I do not wish to make them uncomfortable, and leave if they wish. That has never happened.

In almost every situation, the family or friends are fully aware of my feelings and understand that I will join them once they get grace out of the way. I usually go wash my hands, as much in preparation for eating as anything else. It's my way of giving them the opportunity to do what they want without feeling awkward about me sitting or standing there. On occasion, one or two family members have insisted they wait for me even after being told I do not do grace or prayers. This was just them being the idiots they are because those particular people aren't even religious.

Quite often I do not want to accept invitations for these dinners and that is for a number of reasons I won't bore you with. Infortunately, I have my wife to consider and she comes from a big family (I don't).

I also stated that if they need to pray before they eat in my home, I have no problem if they do so to themselves and not expect me to join in. Unfortunately, some people feel God isn't paying attention unless they make a little show of it. That, in my home, I have a problem with. I don't have much say in who my wife invites, but they all know how I feel about religion. To insist that they openly say grace anyhow, is rude, and a number of you have agreed with that. When I said they should take their prayer outside or all the way home was more out of frustration than what I would actually do. Perhaps I was wrong in expressing myself that way.

I have found that many, not all, but many Christians can be judgemental and many replies on this thread have proven that. Many are also very nice people and consider me their friend even if I am a heathen. They respect my beliefs and stay out of my face with theirs, even though I am open to friendly discussion about the entire issue. I include among those friends a priest, a bishop, and several ministers. Even though we are at odds regarding religion, we remain friends because we respect each other as people. As one might expect, their answers to my issue aren't as objective as I would like, so I reached out to the DIS members for some ideas.

When I started this post I was simply looking for some objective input on how to properly handle the issue of people wanting to say grace in my home. It bothers me that I have created a format for some pretty heavy bickering and that certainly was not my intention. I had hoped for a handfull of replies in which I might find a viable solution for my problem.

As for weddings and funerals (and I'll add christenings), I do not, as a rule, attend church service weddings, funerals, or christenings and while my friends my not like that, they understand. On the rare occasion I must attend a wedding (daughter or son, someday grandchildren) I keep a low profile and do not pretend to be a Christian for the moment. For funerals, I do not attend the church portion and quietly refrain from prayer at graveside. For christenings, I absolutely do not believe in the practice and do not attend, ever, even for my own children and grandchildren. That used to shock a lot of people, but they have come to deal with it.

Regarding the friends who asked me to be godfather to their son, I was, indeed, flattered and did politely decline. I just found it totally out of character for devout Christians to make such a request to someone they knew to be a devout heathen. I guess I tend to look for logic in too many things. By the way, that friendship dwindled because they could not carry on a simple conversation without reference to "the lord." Believe what you want, but please, stay out of my face with it.

I would ask all of you to know that heathens, athiests, and agnostics are people, too. We're not evil and we usually lead good lives. We don't go out trying to recruit members for there is no membership. It's simply what we do or don't believe in in our daily lives. We are as patriotic as anyone and are as willing to help someone in need as anyone. No religion on earth has the market on goodness. It comes in all shapes and sizes... and beliefs. Please accept us for what we are. After all, isn't that the Christian thing to do?

Oh George -- none of this is your fault. I for one admit to overreacting to your post and I'm sorry. You just hit a nerve, I guess. Don't worry about it. I get what you are trying to say.
 
auntpolly said:
And we all know how that never ever bothers you when people comment on bad kids in restaurants!!! :rotfl:

I think if I ever wanted to find you, I'd just start up a thread about some bad kids that were sitting at a table beside me in a restaurant and voila! There you'd be!

I'm really just giving you a hard time, because in all truthfulness I just don't think you are very self aware concerning how you would want to be treated. Are you sure you can take it as well as you can dish it out? ;)

Yep. I can. But I'm not really sure what it is I'm dishing out here in regards to this thread. I said I am polite when people say grace in public, in their homes and in my homes. So, yes I'm okay with people thinking ill of me for brining my children to Jiko, but I would not be okay with them making comments are giving me dirty looks.


As far as these threads, I've ben called all sorts of names on the Dis. I do not call other people names and try very hard to attack the comment, not the person. When I have been wrong here on the Dis, I have apologized and I've even admitted to be wrong. So again, what is it I am dishing out here that you don't think I can take?

This whole debate with me started with me saying that I think ( :rolleyes: ) when I see people in public praying, but I am still polite in my actions and accomodating.

It seems like you are trying very hard to find offense with my first comment on this thread, to the point of dragging up other threads to read more into that first comment. I don't get it, but hey if you really want to dig up some dirt on me spend a couple hours reading through all my other comments and cut and paste them here to "prove" you are right about whatever it is you are tyring to prove you are right about.
 
chobie said:
Yep. I can. .

Ok, if you say so! I know that I kind of changed the way I looked at kids in restaurants because of some of the things you said - you say them in a sort of *cough* strong way, but I got your point.

I can tell that it bothers you when people don't respect you as a person.
 
auntpolly said:
Ok, if you say so! I know that I kind of changed the way I looked at kids in restaurants because of some of the things you said - you say them in a sort of *cough* strong way, but I got your point.

I can tell that it bothers you when people don't respect you as a person.

Right, which is exactly why I would not disrespect others for saying grace in public because I expect the same. Thinking disrepectful thoughts are the not the same as being disrespectful.

And yes, I say things in a strong way and that is why I'm not part of the clicques and why I have not been frosted or blessed. But, the one thing I enjoy about these boards is I don't have to mince words because, its just an internet chat board.
 
And Lord, we are especially thankful for nuclear power, the cleanest,
safest energy source there is. Except for solar, which is just a pipe dream.
Anyway, we'd like to thank you for the occasional moments of peace and
love our family has experienced. Well, not today, but... You saw what
happened! Oh, Lord, be honest! Are we the most pathetic family in the
universe or what!
-- Homer says grace at Thanksgiving dinner, ``Bart vs. Thanksgiving''


dear god, we paid for all this stuff ourselves, so thanks for nothing. --Bart Simpson


rub-a-dub-dub, thanks for the grub


gas is good, it cooks our food.


...just some of versions of saying Grace. :teeth:
 
chobie said:
Right, which is exactly why I would not disrespect others for saying grace in public because I expect the same. Thinking disrepectful thoughts are the not the same as being disrespectful.


I take you at your word.

And to thank you I'll say some silent prayers for you! :teeth:
 
auntpolly said:
I take you at your word.

And to thank you I'll say some silent prayers for you! :teeth:

Well being an agnostic and not an aethist, if you are right I will appreciate those silent prayers!
 
chobie said:
Right but when they do it they are being un PC and that's a good thing. But when we do it we're just horrible. :rolleyes:

No, both sides are pretty horrible! :rotfl:

It's pretty much a tie, but come on guys, there's always room for improvement!
 

PixFuture Display Ad Tag












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top