Years ago I had PF and was tested and put in Brooks Ariel, since they said I over-pronated. I managed to get the PF cleared up, but it came back a year or so later and I switched doctors. This one suggested physical therapy and sent me again to the running store who put me in Asics 2100 series. (I'm not sure which number I started at, but it goes up by 10 each year). I learned that the shoe they put you in when you are healing/doing physical therapy could be different than the one you would be in when you are healed. (I didn't know that)
I have been PF free for several years now, but stayed in the Asics 2160 when I got new shoes in Nov. I used them for my C25K training, ran the Royal 5k in them, and have been using them to train for the ToT. The warning sign that something wasn't right was my knee was bothering me when walking the dog and running. Though I don't have the milage on the shoes (and they look brand new still), the lady at the store said that since I am not overpronating anymore, the combination of the stability shoe and the shoe wearing down could be causing the knee pain. I'm sure the extra 10 pounds I have put on since Feb, when I was already overweight has added to the pounding the shoes have taken.
After trying at least 8 different shoes, I finally settled on Mizuno Wave Enigma. I struggled to make a decision, since the neutral shoe felt lighter and more flexible than the stability shoe I was used to. In the end, though I did like the "familiar" feel of the Asics 2170, I took a chance on the Mizuno, a brand I have never had.
I ran on the treadmill today and loved them! There was no knee pain and overall, they felt comfortable right out of the box. The are expensive little shoes, but I figure I have 2 races coming up now and if the feet are hurt, I can't run, so I just told myself it is an investment! (and I will search for sales for the next pair)
Having two pairs, one for long and one for short runs makes a lot of sense. Which pair do you use to run races in then?
Princess V, what is your perfect shoe? I also like to see what others "love" in their shoes.