justhat
<font color=teal>DC DISer<br><font color=red>pick
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2002
- Messages
- 7,449
A couple very quick thoughts:
- If my wife was set on a name that I didn't like, I suppose that I would come around to accept it, but it would make me a bit sad that she wasn't willing to keep looking for one that we could both agree on.
- I would hope that my vote on the name would count higher than my daughter, mother, sister, or mother in law, all of whom really don't have a vote.
- In my mind, there are only two voters on this; the mother and father. They should each have an equal vote. Therefore, if one disagrees with a name, no majority is attained and the search should continue.
I partially agree with you, but the problem is there is no girl name we both agree on, so point one is sort of not valid. This was proven when we had our first daughter. The ONLY name we both agreed on was Madison, which we obviously used. Middle name was a struggle. We both made a list of names we liked and 2 overlapped-Alyssa and Julia. Alyssa flowed better with Madison, or at least we thought so, so we went with that as her middle name. Julia was fine for me as a middle name, but I don't want it as a first name because I do not at all like the nicknames of Jules or Julie. And whether or not I chose to use them will not matter as other people will. My daughter is and has always been only Madison, yet many camp counselors she's had, my FIL, and random people we meet often call her Maddie. Madison even tells them she's Madison, not Maddie, but it continues.
So that was the only other name we both agreed on, but it's out for me as a first name. At least that's where I am right now with it anyway. So either way one of us is compromising. That also sort of covers point 3, simply cause I haven't encountered a name I like yet that my husband also likes, so no majority can be attained at this point.
The 2nd point, no, no other family members get votes persay, but if they all told me they thought the name was horrible I would seriously reconsider using it. So that's why we told our family our choices because if a bunch of people say it's terrible then I'd look for something else.
Our daughter though, she does get somewhat of a vote in that she is part of the immediate family and we want her to be involved as much as possible. Granted her opinion isn't the most influencial factor by far (her true choice is Rose, as in Briar Rose, her favorite princess), but she does get to help in the decision somewhat. Our son is too little to say anything meaningful, so he hasn't been included. I'm sure his preference would be to name her pirate or firefighter.
Actually, he just told me he wants to name her Henry, shows what I know!The name thing still isn't set in stone, but I know my husband will want to come to an agreement sooner than later cause he's dying to buy a plane ticket for her for next summer with miles before that flight is sold out (of miles flights that is). We can't get the ticket without her first name, so there's that motivation to pick something soon.


MommaMouse and ChristyM
. I don't have a scanner, but I'm going to have someone can them for me and then I will try and upload them.
.