My husband is a draftsman and his office calls CONSTANTLY saking questions. Doies that mean he should carry his computer at all times???? I don't think that is a vaild argument for carrying a gun at all times. I just don't get how that is necessary. We have several LEO's in the family and NONE carry off duty. It is too much of a liability, and none of them feel threatened by the idea of meeting someone they have arrested. When they are off duty they are off duty. They would respond in an emergency, just like I would hope ANY civilian would, but they don't go looking for trouble. They have the same need to carry off duty that any law abiding civilian does, IMO none.
Let me begin by saying that my husband is in probation. Does he always carry he gun? no. We tend to go to a different city than the one he works in when we go out. But sometimes we do go out in the county he works in. There have been many times that he has gotten out of the car when he saw someone who doing something that violated their probation. He spoke with them and told them to report the next day. We are not dealing with people who necessarily respect that he is a LEO. There have been many that he has sent back to jail, put on house arrest, etc. In no way is his carrying a gun a liability, he is certified and knows what he is doing. He does not go looking for trouble. But his needs are totally different than any civilian. Again, until you have had your family and life threaded you really can't understand.
At the same time I don't understand why you would not want a police officer carrying his gun at all times. Police are stretched thin and I personally am happy for any police officer to carry his gun as added protection against what ever may happen. Even for little things like a pocket book being stolen outside a mall.