Lain
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2014
Thanks so much. It seemed like the best option to me, too, but I was hoping there was some "perfect card" out there that would be better. I should have moved on this one before applying for the dumb Citi one. I'll look into the venmo stuff. Is there info on dischurners on there?
Thanks for the info. I need to look up how to use Venmo although I hope we won't have to use it.
First rule: DO NOT do P2P (peer/person-to-peer/person) payments using PayPal, Venmo, etc. between family/relatives/people who share the same last name or address using Amex cards. There are several DPs that Amex will freeze your accounts and hit you with a mini-FR.
2: Chase doesn't care about P2P payments between family/relatives/people who share the same last name or address.
2(a): Venmo used to earn 3x UR on the payment and the fee on the CIP, but that died around February. Venmo now only earns 1x UR on the CIP, so it's really only worth using the CIP on Venmo to help meet MSR.
3: Venmo cares somewhat if you're using their platform for MS, and will freeze or close your account (tying up any of your funds they're holding) if they think you're doing something shady. Venmo has tightened restrictions to limit users to adding only 4 credit/debit cards to your account in a rolling 6 months period. This limits the velocity and utility of liquidating certain MCGC/VGC gift cards as debit (and therefore no fee) through Venmo, and adding new credit cards for MSR. Venmo also has limits on amounts transferred and withdrawn per week unless you take steps to verify your account.
4: Think of Venmo as only a conduit.
If you are doing P2P between you and DD -- say DD adds her CIP to Venmo, and uses the CIP to fund a payment to send you $1k for "reimbursement for moving expenses, thx mom " or "plane tickets, thx for booking ✈" or "Happy birthday mom! " via Venmo (DD > Venmo > You), that's a $1k (+ 3% fee) charge on her CIP, and $1k and change closer to meeting MSR. But DD will also be on the hook for that $1k charge on her credit card bill.
You then need to get that $1k payment back to DD so she can pay her bill. DO NOT send the $1k back to DD via the same conduit (i.e., DD < Venmo < You). Back-and-forth transfers will get you shut down by Venmo. You would withdraw the $1k from Venmo to your bank account, then write DD a check or do an electronic transfer to DD, so that the money gets back to DD's bank account. Once the funds are withdrawn from your Venmo account, Venmo has no idea where those funds go next. It doesn't matter if DD has the same bank as you or not (ideally not the same shared bank account) -- as long as you can get the money back to DD to pay her credit card bill and as long as you don't use Venmo to transfer the funds back to DD.
5: It's a good idea to "season" your Venmo account to establish some pattern or history of transfers, so the occasional $500 or $2k doesn't look like a big deal. For your post-grad aged DD, it looks totally natural for a caring mom to send money for textbooks, lab fees, club dues, tuition, shopping, fun, ski trips, spring break, etc., and it'd be nice if DD reimbursed you for some of these expenses. Be creative. Use those emojis because Venmo is supposed to be a fun "social" way of sending money.
Last edited: