I got six pages into this before jumping to the end here. Here is what will happen. They will enforce the window. You will all piss and moan. You will whine and cry. Then you will plan around it, and spend your money there like we all do every year, no matter what decisions they make. Grow up whine bags.
Just sayin'
The only reason we presently go to a park in the evenings is to use FP that we accumulated during the day. At Epcot, we usually have one for Soarin and one for Test Track collected from in the morning. Generally, a couple in the MK, one for Thunder Mtn. and Space Mtn. In the Studios, one for RR and one for TS Mania. We just get to AK at opening and do EE 2 or 3 times in a row first thing. No reason to use FPs for anything else. We feel that having to wait 2 hours before collecting another FP is enough of a penalty. Disney obviously now feels otherwise. Their parks, their choice to begin enforcing their rules.
Once Disney enforces the rules for the 1 hour window we will rarely tour in the evenings. Our choice. An occasional viewing of Wishes will be it for us.
We understand that Disney is a giant money sucking machine. I suppose that your are right, we will plan around this, but our planning will consist of fewer days in the parks and spending less money there. We are DVC owners so we are immune to the rising costs of staying on-property (take a slight hit when dues trickle up). We eat off-site more and more. We also have Hilton Head as our home resort. Don't have the parks to dominate our vacations there.
I know that I am in the minority but most changes that Disney makes anymore do not enhance the experience of visiting their resorts or parks. Just my opinion, and I know that I am, again, in the minority but I believe that the FP rule 'enforcement' is a precursor to costing park guests money in some form or fashion.
FYI, we just returned from visiting Orlando over President's Day. Stayed off-property at the wonderfull Spring Hill Suites at Sea World. Zipped in and out of AK on Saturday morning / MK on Sunday morning / and Studios on Monday morning with our annual passes.
Spent NO money in any of the parks. Waited in minimal lines and enjoyed a wonderful complimentay breakfast each morning at SH Suites for $135 a night for a modern, over-sized 2 queen room with a fridge, microwave with sleeper sofa and nice size sitting area.
Ate all of our meals off-property and had a very Disney experience.