We were about 10 minutes early, and were handed a pager. Very soon we were lead inside the restaurant and to a table towards the back of the restaurant. There was a small wedding reception going on at the tables behind ours.
The first thing that you notice when you walk into Flying Fish is the noise. It was overwhelming, but due to the fact that the kitchen here is completely open to the rest of the restaurant. There is ample seating at the counter, which I might request to try next time.
Our servers name was Rogelio. He was nice enough, but not very attentive. He was one of the servers for the wedding reception as well, so perhaps he was a bit overwhelmed. We had a very nice view from our table.
We started off with some cocktails!
A Hefeweizen for Adam.
And a blood orange margarita for me. Very tasty and seemingly the same recipe used at La Cava for their blood orange. Only difference was that this had a plain sugar rim.
Bread at butter service. Ok, nothing special.
And then it was time for the good stuff!!
I started with this! Yellowfin Tuna Tartar and Crispy Tempura Tuna-Vegetable Sushi Roll - Hijiki and Wakame Seaweed, Yuzu Tobiko, Wasabi Foam, with Sweet-and-Spicy Sauce $16.00 The sushi roll and tartar were excellent. I don't care for seaweed salads in general. This was no exception. The wasabi foam was nice and added a good heat to the tartare. The soy sauce was excellent with the sushi roll. There was actually some fish in the roll along with the vegetables. I wish there wasn't. Since it was a tempura roll, the tuna ended up being cooked through and wasn't all that appetizing. It really ruined the integrity of the fish, but was still tasty. It was also a very large portion for an appetizer.
Adam started with, not surprisingly, a tomato salad. If you followed along with my first dining report, you know that Adam would probably trade me in for a lifetime supply of fresh, ripe, tomatoes. I on the other hand, cannot stand tomatoes!
Fresh Mozzarella di Bufala - Florida Yellow Beefsteak, Heirloom and Tiny grape Tomatoes, aged Balsamico, Exotic Peppercorns, Petite Basil, and Sicilian Olio Verde $15.00
He claimed this to be very good.
For entree's I couldn't resist their signature item.
Our Signature Flying Fish Café "Potato-wrapped Red Snapper" - Leek Fondue with a Veal Glace, Red Wine, and Cassis Butter reduction $36.00
This was good and went nicely with the red wine reduction. The leeks were very disappointing. Mine were severely underdone and very crunchy. If you've ever had an underdone leek, you know that they are completely unappetizing. The fish was nicely done and the potato wrapping was crispy without being greasy and kept the fish nice and moist on the inside. I probably wouldn't order this again as it didn't really wow me.
It was a "Surf and Surf" special which has mysteriously disappeared from the menu. It was flounder and laughing bird shrimp, and the flounder had a horseradish and bread crumb crust. It was very good as well, the shrimp were outstanding!
Next up was dessert. I had my eye on the boardwalk treats sampler for quite awhile. But our server (who was now a guy named Moh, who was much more attentive than Rogelio) let me know that they were just debuting a new dessert, a Peanut Butter and Jelly Creme Brulee. Say what? I quickly jumped ship and ordere the PB&J Brulee.
That little eye dropper thing that looks like something you would have used in 5th grade science class was filled with chocolate. I chose not to inject it into the brulee.
Oh. My. Word. This was in the top 5 best desserts of ALL TIME! There is a healthy layer of grape jam on the bottom, and then a creamy, thick layer of peanut butter custard on top. The sweetness of the peanut butter (picture the filling of Reese's peanut butter cups, but much creamier) was lightened by the jelly. It was just really delicious.
Adam had this.
Marcona Almond-laced Chocolate Mousse and Sinful Triple Rich Brownie Creation - apple-wood smoked bacon praline crunch, smokey salt-scented chocolate sorbet and raspberry coulis $8.00
This was also very good, but not nearly as amazing as mine!
Overall we had an enjoyable meal here. It was salvaged by the incredible desserts. In the future I would definitely come by for dessert, but I wasn't wowed by the entree offerings.