You'd understand the comment if you realized I have now been booked at three resorts since July (four, if you count the Poly twice) and came thisclose to at least three others. (I should change my DISboard identity to hide the evidence.
A Disney newbie, I originally, naively, started with the Animal Kingdom Lodge, because the animals looked fun. Then I got the Unofficial Guide and started worrying about the location/transportation. Decided on Polynesian and then discovered these boards. Started reading some really distressing reviews and then SERIOUSLY started second-guessing. Upgraded to club level and then started hearing bad reviews about that too, which brought me to a full-on panic. (Well, not really "panic," but it WAS occupying a good junk of my time.)
Considered switch to just about every resort but didn't pull the trigger until discounts came out and no Poly available for our dates. Then, ever since the switch (to Yacht Club), worried about no monorail resort/fireworks viewing for my son, who is very excited about both. Stalked discount website daily (OK, let's face it, multiple times per day) and finally found availability at both Grand Floridian and Polynesian, then went into another tizzy again about which one of those was "best" choice for our family.
In the end, the recent good reviews--some from people who expressed the concerns as I did--the overall theme of Polynesian (kid-friendly), the location/fireworks viewing options and, in no small part, the almost $500 lower price tag of the Poly won me over and I actually feel good about the choice.
So, you know, it's no small thing.
As I said on another thread ... I've got my dining set (overhauled, again, when we changed resorts, again), flights secured and finalized, itinerary pretty well filled in (or as filled as I want it, which is still probably more filled than we'll actually end up doing) and it's starting to feel real that we're going. Now I've just gotta make it through the 2-1/2 month wait to actually get there.
Oh and, yes, I am anal retentive, thanks for asking, but this is a vacation over-planning first for me. I've always been a researcher, but never to this extent. Disney just brings it out in me, I guess ... Wanna see my color-coded daily itinerary for the trip? (And, yes, I am kidding about sharing it, but, umm, yeah, I really do have one.)