Why not buy the cheapest home resort??

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally posted by SimbaCub
One thing to keep in mind, and yes I do work with statistics on a day to day basis, the largest number of room right now is at OKW. Thus, it doesn't take much if just a "few" members trade out or book rooms at other DVC resorts before a large number of rooms becomes available. PamOKW is correct in her explanation--I don't know if I could have explained quite so well so you deserve a pat on the back!! To state that the resort is underutilized is mixing apples and oranges--a pet peeve of mine when people who do NOT know how to make statistical analysis of an issue try to do this to prove a point--because the cause and effect relationships do not exist. Would that explain why both BWV and BCV still have openings for next May? They too are being underutilized? No, it would not.

As for some of DeePs "issues" with statements about BWV, I have stayed there only 3 times and have never been "near" the elevator but at the end of the hall. When I returned after a long day in the parks that walk did feel like 5 miles--especially right after knee surgery. Then again, on my 4 stays at one of my home resorts of OKW walking up the stairs felt like I was climbing Mt Everest so the same thing can be said about both of those resorts: At the end of the day unless you have a room right by the elevator AND the elevator is not too far away, it will ALWAYS feel like a long walk/hike to your room. Regarding trash in the hallways at BWV, I don't mean any offense so please don't take it this way, BUT I have only seen trash outside the rooms at BWV. NEVER at any of my 3 stays at VWL or my 4 trips to OKW or my 2 trips to HHI. Now, does this mean I won't stay there? No, but given I have stayed only 3 times at BWV out of my 12 visits on points--this amounts to 25% of my visits by the way--I cannot say whether or not this is a normal condition. Given the number of stays members have had in the same number of years I have stayed, I would state I don't have the "statistical" confidence to say that BWV looks "trashy" because of the trash outside the doors even though I have seen it there each visit. It would require a lot of data gathering and to be honest, I don't have the time nor do I have the inclination to gather the right amount of data to provide my fellow DVC owners that statistic--sorry folks but that would be a lot of data!! Still, take it with a grain of salt because only those items we DVC owners see that we don't expect to see due to our high standards makes it on these boards. I have never thought to look at the other resorts but if people feel it's a problem then tell DVC management.

I will be taking friends to BCV next May to see that resort as I have not stayed there yet. I do like to try out the other resorts though most of my trips have been to my 2 home resorts. I bought points there to ensure I could stay there during peak times. In addition, only BWV and OKW were open when I bought OKW so there were no other options for people to stay at hence the reason BWV had been so heavily booked at the beginning--the newness and the sheer number of members who owned at OKW. For those of you who have BWV as your home resort, be happy BWV is booked, it means people like to visit your home resort!! Me, I like the idea that if I make a last minute trip I know I can most likely get into OKW. Shh, it's a little secret a lot of people don't realize!! A trip to WDW is better than no trip at all, right? ;)

And for those who doubt the fact I was told I "stole a room from a BWV owner" by booking at the 7 month point, rest assured this incident did indeed occur in May 02. I still feel this member was the rare one in voicing this opinion but it did and still does sting. Keep in mind that many of us do have strong opinions about our home resorts but that doesn't give us the right to insult each other or make accusations like the one I had.

Please, remember if you are going to use statistics to use them properly because it gives those of us who work in the business a bad name when you brandish numbers all over the place without knowing how to use them. I would never dream of telling people how to put a filling on a tooth when I am not a dentist, I leave that to Doc!! :teeth:

SimbaCub

2 Days Until VWL
There most certainly is a way to do a statistical analysis on the room occupancies at the various DVC resorts, it just has not been done by either side of those throwing around the demands for official DVC sanctioned info.
As far as a dentist and getting a tooth filled.......how is that relevant to anything on this board or dealing with a DVC membership???????????????
Thank you for crediting me with all the "issues" from this thread but there were many others who have posted on this thread with "issues" than just me, BUT thank you for remembering me, it makes me feel soooooooo special.
I do not have "issues" with people getting annoyed at finding trash at BWV or any resort, what I do get annoyed with is people referring to BWV owners as slobs, stupid, embarrassed, etc. There is no need for name calling, nor is there any need for blatent lies like: the halls are 5 miles long, the rooms are so small they are essentially useless, etc. etc.
 
Originally posted by Desperado
So, I guess OKW is absolutely perfect as it currently is and there is no room for any improvement to make it a more attractive option for DVC members making reservations (home resort owners or owners of other resorts), nor should any improvements dare be suggested as part of a discussion about percieved imbalance in demand levels. Soliciting possible suggestions for OKW resort improvement from other posters and OKW owners is not appropriate and a guise for resort condemnation and a claim that the OKW resort is not being enjoyed as is.

I stand corrected.

overpape2.gif


Outstanding news!!!!! It looks like OKW will be getting an additional amenity in the form of a Pool Slide for the main pool. This report came from the last OKW meeting.

Fabulous news, I hope this report is confirmed. This will be a wonderful addition to the resort. Outstanding!!!!!!!!!!!.


:bounce: :bounce: :bounce: :bounce: :bounce: :bounce: :bounce:
 

Aaargh. Can you please start a new thread about the pool slide so this one can rest in peace. ;) Is there another thread with the news from the OKW meeting? Sounds interesting.
 
I have to agree with Pam. This horse is dead. Stop beating it!
 
With the addition of a pool slide at OKW, the cheapest home resort might not remain the cheapest much longer!
Guess I will have to seriously rethink my idea of selling my BWV points, buying OKW points and then never staying at OKW but instead staying at the other DVC resorts, just to save money on the dues! LOL!
 
Originally posted by dianeschlicht
I have to agree with Pam. This horse is dead. Stop beating it!
I understand that this new news may not be supportive of the points you and others were attempting to make in the discussion, or limitations some posters were imposing only to support thier own views when they weren't being successful with other approaches.

However, the announcement of a slide for OKW is certainly very new news that that was not available for the previous discussion in this thread. This new news, if true, is a major concrete change and directly applies to the suggestions that some possible amenities for OKW should not be off limits for discussion, or meet with such hostile and abusive responses as some of the posts in this thread. If the reports from the meetings are correct, this change is now a planned fact well beyond speculative discussion.

I'm glad to see OKW get this new improvement. I'm also glad to see DVC take this positive approach that addresses some of the issues discussed above, (even if those issues were not the cause of the decision).

Congraduations to those currently making reservations and planning on making future reservations at OKW. This new addition makes a nice OKW resort, even nicer.
 
Originally posted by Desperado
I understand that this new news may not be supportive of the points you and others were attempting to make in the discussion, or limitations some posters were imposing only to support thier own views when they weren't being successful with other approaches.

However, the announcement of a slide for OKW is certainly very new news that that was not available for the previous discussion in this thread. This new news, if true, is a major concrete change and directly applies to the suggestions that some possible amenities for OKW should not be off limits for discussion, or meet with such hostile and abusive responses as some of the posts in this thread. If the reports from the meetings are correct, this change is now a planned fact well beyond speculative discussion.

I'm glad to see OKW get this new improvement. I'm also glad to see DVC take this positive approach that addresses some of the issues discussed above, (even if those issues were not the cause of the decision).

Congraduations to those currently making reservations and planning on making future reservations at OKW. This new addition makes a nice OKW resort, even nicer.

Just thought I'd quote everything since you like to do that. ;) Most people just add a response. We can all generally figure out what it is in response to.

THIS thread was about

Why not buy the cheapest home resort??

Adding a pool actually just makes this a better idea. If what was lacking at OKW was a pool, why not buy there and stay there or at any of the other resorts? Let's take the pool discussion to the pool thread. :)
 
Originally posted by PamOKW
THIS thread was about_
The original poster's second post said:
Originally posted by DeeP
I know I am going to get called out for these statements, but I get called out for a lot of statements I make on this board, so what the heck! LOL!!
Start up the flames, but I am sorry, using a DVC membership with the pattern that Kansas is using theirs is not right. You do not buy a membership purposely at the resort with the lowest dues knowing full darn well you will mostly always be reserving rooms at the other higher priced dues resorts. I don't care if you are legit in getting the rooms at 7 months or not, if you mainly wanted to stay at the higher priced DVC resorts, which are priced that way because they offer more to their guests in terms of location and amenities, pools, restaurants, etc., I don't care how you slice the pie, if you want to stay in these resorts for the majority of your trips then you should be paying the higher dues.
I feel the same way about people that constantly pool hop because they are not happy with OKW's pool or that regularly park at the Epcot and MK resorts so they do not have to park in the lots at the parks. I am sorry if you want those things and intend to make this your resort choice the vast majority of the time due to these things, location, etc., then you should have bought at one of these resorts and should be paying the higher dues that support these extended amenities.
Kansas is only one person from a very small number of DVC members that we see on these boards that employs this money saving technique, I wonder how many other members do the same thing. I know OKW has the largest amount of rooms but it would be very intersting to see the actual % of OKW owners that trade out on a regular basis to other WDW DVC resorts or how many on a regular basis pool hop, valet park or even self park for park access etc. Again I know OKW has the largest amount of rooms about double of BWV, but come on OKW is always available. I have never been told there was not at least something at OKW no matter what time of the year I have tried to make reservations and no matter how close to the trip. I go to WDW every 3 months or less so I have been there alot and I will admit I hardly ever make reservations at 11 months--I can't, I am there too often, and I am never sure of excat dates. As an owner at BWV and gladly paying the highest of the DVC WDW dues, I will admit it does get frustrating when I have to juggle my dates to get into my own home resort and yet OKW is always available.
It would be very interesting if DVC could some how keep track of the % of owners that trade out of their home resort on a regular basis to stay at other WDW DVC resorts.
Ok, flame away!
This clearly brings in the other issues and opportunity to discuss OKW amenities by the person who started the thread. You didn't start the thread, as much as you have repeatedly attempted to control what you think should be in it.

There is no good reason listing a pool along with other potential amenity improvements as part of this discussion should have met with the rude and personally attacking responses it did in my opinion.
Just thought I'd quote everything since you like to do that. Most people just add a response. We can all generally figure out what it is in response to.
:rolleyes:
I guess when one cannot adequately support thier stance, they need to resort to personally disparaging comments. Seems uncalled for.

Enjoy the new slide, OKW owners and guests. And take a look at the recent poll results that are occurring now about the OKW slide, especially those folks who kept citing previous polls that "overwhelmingly" turned down an OKW slide, and the accompanying posts of people stating increased interest instaying at the resort. http://disboards.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=476692
blowingup.gif
 
Originally posted by Desperado
(To dianeschlicht)
I understand that this new news may not be supportive of the points you and others were attempting to make in the discussion, or limitations some posters were imposing only to support thier own views when they weren't being successful with other approaches.

It unfortunate that you have had to resort to such unprovoked personal attacks. dianeschlicht simply posts a desire to see the thread end, and you choose to publicly berate her for her comments.


I guess when one cannot adequately support thier stance, they need to resort to personally disparaging comments. Seems uncalled for.

And exactly how do you see your behavior as being any different than what you describe above? Pam's reply was clearly intended to be tongue-in-cheek as evidenced by the smiley, and you berate her for making a constructive suggestion. Seems uncalled for.


Enjoy the new slide, OKW owners and guests. And take a look at the recent poll results that are occurring now about the OKW slide, especially those folks who kept citing previous polls that "overwhelmingly" turned down an OKW slide, and the accompanying posts of people stating increased interest instaying at the resort.

I, for one, am immensely gratified that we can finally lay to rest the Great OKW Pool Debate of 2003. Can I get a round of "Joy to the World", DVC style???

:grouphug:
 
thumbsdown.gif

Sorry, but throwing in a smiley face doesn't magically transform a non-constructive "uncalled for" comment that may be more appropriate as a PM.;) As you know, I've used PMs to express concerns over personally attacking posts.;)

My error, I didn't realize this wasn't a discussion but rather a debate which implies "winners" and "losers". Perhaps that's been the problem, some trying "win" and cause others to be loosers, as in a debate. Earlier in the thread I was just trying to reasonably discuss alternatives and solutions to concerns, and admittedly got frustrated given the dysfunctional responses. Looks like there is new news within the last day that one of those discussed suggestions for an additional OKW amenity was adopted by DVC. Apparently, DVC determined an OKW improvement is appropriate. Of course, it is doubtful that a simple pool slide will address all the concerns raised above, and we don't know the reasons behind it, but appears to be a step in the right direction, and it's great to see so many people jumping on board and expressing appreciation for the OKW improvement. I hope to see more improvement happening at all the resorts.
 
Originally posted by Desperado
thumbsdown.gif

Sorry, but throwing in a smiley face doesn't magically transform a non-constructive "uncalled for" comment that may be more appropriate as a PM.;) As you know, I've used PMs to express concerns over personally attacking posts.;)

My error, I didn't realize this wasn't a discussion but rather a debate which implies "winners" and "losers". Earlier in the thread I was just trying to reasonably discuss alternatives and solutions to concerns, and admittedly got frustrated given the responses. Looks like there is new news within the last day that one of those discussed suggestions for an additional OKW amenity was adopted by DVC. Apparently, DVC determined the OKW improvement is appropriate. Of course, it is doubtful that a simple pool slide will address all the concerns raised above, but appears to be a step in the right direction, and it's great to see so many people jumping on board and expressing appreciation for the OKW improvement. I hope to see more improvement happening at all the resorts.

What, no quotes this time?

I find it interesting that you continue to call out others for perceived instances of rude and insulting behavior, when you've been dishing it out just the same.

Personally, I don't need to hide behind PMs to make the comments that I want to make.
 
I repeat:
I have to agree with Pam. This horse is dead. Stop beating it!

Let me explain that comment to you. I mearly thought the topic of the thead had been beaten around over and over again. No one is going to convince anyone of anything else by repeating everything over for the 100th time. The pool discussion DOES belong on the pool thread. It is different from the topic of this thread. So sorry you see me as an enemy, but I have not even posted much at all on this thread compared to what I would LIKE to say!
 
Originally posted by tjkraz
What, no quotes this time?

I find it interesting that you continue to call out others for perceived instances of rude and insulting behavior, when you've been dishing it out just the same.

Personally, I don't need to hide behind PMs to make the comments that I want to make.
Well put! I don't ever remember attacking Desperado or the ideas.
 
My intention was to ask you not to use the quote function so much. It makes the posts very long and the bold is somewhat annoying to read. It's not meant as a personal attack at all and I'm sorry if you felt that it was. Maybe you felt the lines of bold-type added a menancing tone to the post -- if you did, that's what I was trying to tell you about your use of the quote function also. It's meant the same way it is when I ask someone to not use all caps in their posts. The majority of people use the quote in moderation to add emphasis.

Now, that makes what, 400 different topics in this thread? :)
 
Instructing someone on how to make posts on this board is not a related topic and really that post should be removed. It is amazing how sometimes this "rule" in enforced and sometimes it is not! :rolleyes:
Wanna place a bet on how long this post will last though??? :teeth:
 
OMG! This thread has come back from the dead! The horror! The horror!!!!!!!!:eek:
 
Now who is attacking who? All the time people ask folks not to type in caps, colored italics, etc. The person is free to do whatever they like -- Desperado can keep using quotes, I was just bringing something to his attention. Way back when bandwidth was at a premium here, we were told not to use the quotes unless absolutely necessary. I have no idea why my posts are attacked. I honestly don't know what is offensive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

















DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top