Just finished my first trip to
Disneyland and LOVED it. We did Extra Magic Hour for both parks, and this is the order we did it in (worked out great for us):
DCA: (Monday May 9, 2016)
1. Luigi's Rollickin Roadsters
2. Radiator Springs Racers
3. Mater's Junkyard Jamboree
^^ Got those all done in well under an hour (RSR wait was about 15 min standby), and managed to get over to Toy Story Midway Mania right after, and the wait was still only 5 minutes!
Disneyland: (Tuesday May 10, 2016)
1. Peter Pan
2. Mr. Toad
3. Alice
4. Matterhorn
5. Pinocchio
6. Snow White
^^ Got all of those done in the first hour! And then ran over to Tomorrowland and grabbed at FP for Space Mountain. Now, I don't know if those results are typical for an Extra Magic Hour/Magic Morning, but we were THRILLED with how well we did! Granted, we lined up at the gates at about 7:15am for an 8am EMH, and were right up at the front by the rope when it dropped.
Anyway, that's my VERY recent first-timer experience, hope that's helpful.