horselover
Why yes I would love a glass of wine!
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2008
- Messages
- 2,707
Assuming they were to outfit some of the lodge rooms as DVC, and in such a manner that they were the exact same layout as what we have now in VWL, who here would prefer to book in the main lodge over VWL?
Not I. I love the peace and quiet, the fireplaces, the covered walkway, the hidden springs pool right off the back door and of course the VWL lobby. I wouldn't give it up. Not even if they made 1br units with 2 bathrooms over in the lodge.
Concierge in the main lodge for a night or 2 just for something different sure, but for a non-concierge stay absolutely not. I agree with everything you said above. The villas are a peaceful oasis. The main lodge as beautiful as it is is not peaceful.
Yes, still lurking around on my favorite thread, with my favorite Disney Nuts . . . thanks to all of you for giving me a place I can quickly go in between events here at the mill.
Thought I would let you all in on a quick view of what I drive an hour for every day . . .
Usually I am alone, but some days there are as many as five of us sharing the space (and air) of my little shipping container. I think the bars on the windows are to keep lite fingers out at night, but maybe they are just to keep me in . . not sure . .
No wonder I need a VWL fix more often now . . .
Wow you're truly living in style DisnyDad!

Ok, so my first hurdle was to put aside my love and devotion to the lodge and think about this as a consumer.
Disney is suffering from some major issues that are not getting them the profit margins and/or the occupancy rates they want.
First and foremost, as much as I love the lodge and many of the Disney deluxes, they are extremely and routinely overpriced. Now for most return visitors we know and accept this and we also find other areas to cut back (such as purchasing dvc) BUT.....
The vacationing public is getting smarter and savvier and the competition is fighting harder for those vacation dollars.
In the hotel business, the mouseworld's offerings cannot justify the price they need to offer to capture those who are going to routinely wish to stay close to the parks.
Dh and I stayed at the Waldorf Astoria Orlando for a long anniversary weekend. 30% cheaper and the difference is startling. Now a 4 seasons is set to open in Orlando near Disney in 2015.
the question can be asked, if you did not own DVC would you stay at one of the deluxes. For many, myself included, not without a hefty discount. So either way your profit margins disappear. either you give up a big price reduction or you risk moving folks to better offerings.
The information I've garnered is that most Disney deluxes run at about 70% occupancy.
converting that inventory to dvc is not going to fix that bleed.
Speaking from the perspective of someone that sells it it is rare I get a request for a deluxe anymore. 99% of the requests I get are for moderates especially now that most of the mods have 2 queens instead of 2 doubles. People just don't want to pay those prices considering how little they are actually in the room.
If I wasn't an owner it's not likely I'd be paying for deluxe without a really nice discount as you mentioned. As much as we loved staying in the lodge the first time back in 2008 I could not see our family of 4 crammed into one of those rooms. The bunk rooms are great when the kids are small but with teenagers not so much.