Yes, VGF1 did get the Murphy-over-sofa to replace the queen sofa beds.
Vloggers and I agree that a Murphy bed mattress isn't as comfortable as a regular one. They're more comfy than those yukky queen sofa beds but not as supportive as a regular mattress.
Esthetically, I'd much rather be in a room with 2 queens and a sofa. I think it's a pain to have to raise the Murphy to have daytime seating.
Closer to parking, I'll grant you. That could be a strength of VGF1, inadequate though that lot is when there's a wedding next door.
Split bath, same. Hadn't thought of that since we don't get it in the accessible DH needs.
The dedicated check-in? Well, maybe. But not if VGF2 guests can check in at the GF front desk. That could negate any check-in advantage VGF1 has, IMO.
Not getting wet, okay. We don't go during downpour season, but I agree that might be a factor for those who do.
Bottom line, I suspect spaciousness and not cooking are more important factors favoring VGF2, although parking inconvenience might offset those slightly. Maybe not if more with no car also don't cook. No telling how many VGFers don't drive and have Owner's Locker.