I've heard there are very few rooms that have this "special" view. We were on the third floor facing the port, also, and only saw a bunch of lights that we assumed were the ships. You could tell Carnival because of that distinctive fin thingie they have on their ships and it did block the Magic. I have to agree with clh2, though, because it is pretty far away to have a decent view. Definately not worth any extra money if they charge for that.