I was at POR over this Spring Break March 2005 and it was renovated. Very nice! I have only stayed at POR so I can't really compare the resorts in depth, but we did visit POFQ to swim in the pool. I liked the appearance of our resort better, it seemed less hotel-ish and more resort like. We also enjoy the breakfasts at Boatwrights, the table service restaurant at POR. POFQ has no sit down restaurant. Lots of people do like the compactness of POFQ over POR although my family has never felt it to be too spread out there. My whole family, ages 7 to 65, love POR. Hope this helps!