I've been reading for years on this board about the strict parking rules at both the Contemporary and Poly, and maybe that's why I was so shocked by my experiences last week. I visited the week after Easter - a super busy time, and here were my experiences. I was staying on site at Old Key West, but now that they don't give you parking passes, there was nothing to designate me or my car as "onsite."
1. On our arrival day, we had an 11:30 breakfast ADR at 'Ohana. We had not yet checked into our resort yet. We pulled right into the Poly parking lot at 11:00 and told the guy at the booth that we had breakfast reservations. He asked to see ID, glanced at my drivers license, and waved us through - nothing was said to us about not staying past 3 hours, he didn't check some list of ADRs, and he didn't see or ask to see Magic Bands. There was plenty of parking at the Poly. We could have stayed parked there all day had we wanted to. We didn't, and wouldn't, but it was definitely possible, and since nothing was said to us, it wouldn't have been like we were breaking any sort of rules.
2. On our last day, my parents were heading out of town and my husband, son, and I had an 8 AM Crystal Palace reservation. My parents dropped us off at the Contemporary around 7:30 so we could walk into the MK rather than playing bus roulette that early in the morning. When we pulled into the Contemporary, my dad, who was not wearing a Magic Band, just told the guy at the booth, "we're going to breakfast." Again, he was asked to show ID, the CM glanced at the license, and waved us through. The CM didn't ask where we were having breakfast, check a list of ADR's, or anything. Now, my dad didn't even park, he just pulled into a parking spot so we could get out and walk to the MK, but again, my dad could have parked his car anywhere he wanted in the Contemporary lot and stayed all day, and no one would have known or cared.
Two very similar experiences during a super busy week. I was really surprised. Given what I had read on the boards over the years, I had a screen shot of my ADRs and my Magic Bands ready to show.