That's probably because no other restaurant in the world has anything to do with the #1 tourist destination...........They could use that extra $10 per cancellation/no-show to help pay for the nighttime fireworks spectaculars (instead of reducing them) which I'm fairly certain your neighbor's restaurants don't do. But correct me if I'm wrong.
There are only 70+ TS sites at WDW and Disney is simply protecting their investment. I'm not sure I understand why so many people on this thread are !
Your wrong. There is zero evidence to think the revenue from this charge will be used to pay for fireworks spectacular.
If Disney is taking drastic steps such as these (and yes, it is drastic for a faimly of ANY size to pay out money for nothing if a child falls ill or if someone is exhausated and cannot make a ressie (risking further health issues if they continue) then they are truly missing the mark. Punishing everyone for the mistakes of a few is never a wise choice.![]()

Disney's trying to ADJUST guest behavior. Instead of just not showing up for that ADR you will now have to cancel it. ....
........Nobody likes having to pay more - but there it is.
It's not clear if this is an attempt to adjust guest behavior or simply a way to have guests pay more. People can still cancel the day before. This change will have little effect on guests who book ADRs on "spec".
It seems, in most cases (not all), those who are the most upset are the same ones who cancelled for not so valid reasons.
Unfortunately, based on the DIS alone there seems to be more than a small amount of abuse, & we're just a minuscule number of WDW guests.
It doesn't seem like that to me at all. I've never been a "no show" for an ADR and I don't think I've ever canceled an ADR I don't make ADRs "on spec".
I don't want a system which penalizes me if a family member becomes ill. I certainly don't want a system which results in families with screaming kids deciding to keep an ADR rather then lose money.
Do the math. Assume a family with at one more kids. One or more free kids. The total cancellation fee is 30-50% the cost of the meal.