I’ve softened on Enchantment over time. I was unhappy when they announced it and unmoved when I saw it (albeit on YouTube) for the first time. When I saw it in the park I didn’t hate it, but I don’t think that is the response they should be trying to attain.
Ultimately, it’s biggest failure from my perspective is that it’s not HEA. HEA was basically everything i didn’t know I wanted in a fireworks show from the first time I saw it. I’m all for changing the projections over time and updating the arrangement to fit, but the theme and the song just hit so much of what a day in the parks and Disney, in general, mean to me.