It seems to get relatively good reviews on the Dis, at least for the "fun" factor but we did not really like it. It was ediable but not anything to write home about. Ribs were covered in sauce but dry inside; chicken was OK; corn fine; potatoes good but it's hard to make bad potatoes; corn bread was terrible...phewwy!! Dry, dry, dry!!
Asking for ketchup & getting a 100 bottles was fun & getting the extra, extra, extra large glass of water for my VERY thirsty ten year old was cute. We did it, it was OK but honestly, with all the good restaurants Disney has, we won't go back.