Actually I am right there with you about the barbeque on CC. I was pretty underwhelmed with it, but I too felt like the only one. My friends go wild over everything. Sometimes I think it's more psychological - that because we are on vacation and a pricey cruise everything is just simply divine, even though it isn't. Don't get me wrong, it's all good but I don't do cartwheels over average to above average things, especially when it's food. I also fully admit that I am a food snob, so I certainly never complain or otherwise dilute the magic.
More questions:
Am I allowed to order off the adult menu for my kids? My kids have had very diverse foods all their lives and I'm inclined to have them eat more than mac n cheese. For Mallory on our first cruise I ordered off the kids menu, but I guess I never thought about the adult menu. Now that she eats 100% of what we eat I figure it might be good to have the option.
And, on this potty thing in the kids club. Mallory goes to day care and they use the potty without assistance most of the time. If it's #2 I know the staff helps them if needed, but otherwise they're independent. I'm guessing there's no help available for that in the kids club? Also, are the toilets in the kids club the kind that auto flush? And are they small or adult size? Mallory is afraid of the auto flush ones - they always flush before she finishes and it freaks her out.
And I think you are right about the seafood brunch. Our friends really like to eat at the buffets for breakfast and lunch on at sea days (not me!) and I bet that is exactly what happened. They said it was on the second day at sea. I have palo brunch that day.
Very excited for fish extenders... How we doing on the tally for that? And will we meet up on the boat at some point?