I'll add my two cents on this. I've had no problems booking two rooms under different promos with the same people and the same lead person for the same time period, while I figured out which room / discount I wanted to keep, but cancelled one room before any havoc happened in
MDE. I did this as recently as this summer - I had a room discount bounceback for YC WV for my family of 4 and when
free dining came out, I grabbed the exact same room and dates for the exact same people while I figured out which discount was better. I held on to both reservations for a few weeks and then cancelled the free dining. I also have seen many APers grab multiple rooms so they can invite friends and family to join them (as an AP, you can book up to 3 rooms for the same period, so friends and family can travel with you).
However, if you call in (and for some discounts, such as bouncebacks, you HAVE to call in), they will
not allow you to put the same person in different rooms for the same time period. This just happened to me, I wanted to grab 2 rooms for May in case my kids wanted to go to Disney with friends, so I wanted to put the family in both rooms and then call and change, and the CM did not allow.
Regular room at a moderate was not available with 30% off (only preferred room, which coincidentally was 30% more!), but CL at GF was available, albeit, it was 35% off or maybe a little less, trying to figure out why it was a bit higher). Can you share the numbers? I'm a bit surprised that they had 40% off. It's the first time I've heard of a HIGHER discount.
NOOOO! Yes, bouncebacks *can* be changed. However, there has to be availability with the promo for the new dates. Not every room is discounted and in fact we saw a total dearth of CL discounts in 2024 with a bounceback. Possibly she saw no discount and simply said it could not be changed, but that is inaccurate.
Highly recommend to mosey over to the Bounceback thread (link in my signature) where we have all the latest info on bouncebacks!
YES! They must get incentives. They push the packages. They push the dining plan. They push the memory maker. Just say thank you if not interested in those components.