Still trying to wrap my brain around never having stockings because there was no fireplace. My mother cross stiched beautiful stockings for every member of our family. We cherish them and still as above 50yo kids, fill our stockings at our family Christmas celebration.
Stocking stuffers can be simple or expensive, your choice.
I always put a tangerine in the toe. There is always gelt.
Boys get batteries, flashlights, mini tools, candy, fun toys(yoyo,puzzles,decks of cards) All would be great girl object too. Girls get lipsticks, nail polish, eye shadow, nail files, little tissue packs, CD's, gum and more. If you look at every checkout counter starting now, you will find myriad of things appropriate for stockings. I always get something long that will stick out of DS's stocking. My sister always gets us those 4 piece boxes of Godiva. My husband buys things like those multicolored balls of rubber bands, colored paperclips, scotch tape. We all come with a few things for the stockings so there's not pressure on just one person to stuff them all. Lol, My sister always buys herself some expensive jewelry and puts it in her own stocking-last year, I moved it to mine, you should have seen the look on her face, tee hee.