Here's a tip...
When you go to check in, MAKE SURE you tell them that you are checking in.
Specifically mention the words "checking in" to avoid all confusion.
Now the long story that goes with that advice...
We had a reservation at the Blue Bayou, and we showed up 20 minutes before our time (which was right when they opened because we wanted a seat by the water as well). We were about the 5th group of people waiting there. As soon as we got there, We went to the hostess and told her that we were "here for our 11:00 reservation." She looked on her computer and "confirmed my appointment." I thought that meant we were good to go, so we waited around like everyone else was doing for the restaurant to open.
When they opened (at 11:00) they started calling names out. We though it was a bit weird when they called some names and people we knew had showed up later than us were seated first, but we figured they knew what they were doing. Finally, everyone who had 11:00 reservations had been seated and we were still waiting around for our name to be called. Now it seemed like they were taking walk-in's. I was curious as to why they had called everyone and were now taking walk-ins while we were still waiting for our names to be called.
At this point, I was confused, so I went and asked why our names weren't called. I figured they thought they called us, but hadn't, and it was just a fluke. Nope. The hostess told me, "You didn't check in, you just confirmed you reservation. Would you like to check in now?"
I asked her what the difference was. She replied that all I had done was confirm that I did indeed have a reservation at 11:00, but I hadn't actually confirmed to her that I was there for my reservation. I asked her if, when I said, "We're here for our 11:00 reservation," she honestly took that to mean that we were just curious whether we had one, as if we were randomly walking around New Orleans Square and we suddenly got the idea to just approach her and see if, by chance, our names happened to be on the reservation list. She replied that I shouldn't have said, "We're here for our 11:00 reservation," we should have said, "We're here to check in for our 11:00 reservation."
I asked her why she though I would have shown up at the same time as everyone else who had an 11:00 reservation, gone over to her and and told her we were there for our 11:00 reservation like everyone else had done, then stood there and waited around for the 11:00 reservation if all we wanted to do was "confirm that we had an 11:00 reservation" but not check in for our reservation.
She very rudely replied that it wasn't her fault that I didn't know to tell her that I was checking in instead of just confirming my appointment.
... You know that crazy guy you always see at
Disneyland who is making a big scene because something didn't go his way? That day, I became that crazy guy. I had booked the reservation as far out as I could, literally 90 days in advance, to the day. I called Disney a week before my trip to make sure my reservation was still there. I arranged that morning's schedule to be at the Blue Bayou 20 minutes early to ensure that I would get a seat by the water, and now, thanks to this braindead hostess, That wasn't going to happen. I told her that, as a hostess, if she couldn't figure out that someone showing up and saying "I'm here for my reservation" was actually there for their reservation, that she must have been the stupidest person to ever have worked at Disneyland.
At this point, the manager noticed the argument, came over to get us, and took us to our seat. He asked what happened, and I told him. After we were seated, I took a moment to cool off. I decided that I wasn't going to let the stupid hostess or the argument ruin my meal. My meal was indeed very good. It's just unfortunate that it started off so terrible. I've never had such a bad experience with a Disney cast member before or since.
So basically, on the off chance that the same hostess is still working there, and she's still too dumb to do her job, it might be a good idea to clearly and specifically state that you are checking in for your reservation. If you plan on relying on her to put any brain behind her job, you might be disappointed, and you might not get your table by the water.