American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[ImMarcik]

I can't get through to Taylor at all.

 

[DisneyGerry]

Looks like Taylor will win over McPhee unless she can sing 'Over the Rainbow' a few more times. Taylor looked much more at ease and I think was the best for each of the 3 songs.

 

[llij]

I could only get through once for Kat. I think Taylor has this thing locked up though!

 

[lizardqueen]

I think it will be Taylor vs Elliott. I can't get through for Taylor at all. DH wants to know why I bother voting because "it's fixed anyway".

 

[damo]

The songs were too short.

 

[Reflection]

Isn't that why it's a competition, some people think he can sing and he gets votes, others think he can't sing and therefore don't vote for him. My opinion against your opinion.

Yes, absolutely this is a competition and there definitely will be different opinions.

Am I the first one who said they couldn't stand someone?

No, you are not the first, and I'm quite certain you won't be the last.

So, your buzz lightyear - CAN
And I'm Woody - CAN'TRayJay

Okay.

 

[plove53]

was the order of performances elliot, kat, taylor? i only saw part of the middle and dont know which number songs they were on...

 

[damo]

was the order of performances elliot, kat, taylor? i only saw part of the middle and dont know which number songs they were on...

Elliott 1-4-7
Kat 2-5-8
Taylor 3-6-9

 

[Samandmom]

Ok so when Taylor made the top 12, I kept saying why?!?!

NOW I want him to win it all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
got threw twice already, DH is on the other line voting for Mchphee!

 

[lbgraves]

Looks like Taylor will win over McPhee unless she can sing 'Over the Rainbow' a few more times. Taylor looked much more at ease and I think was the best for each of the 3 songs.

Don't they get to sing their favorite in the finals? I remember having to listen to Fantasia sing Summertime again. If so, Kat will be singing it next week too.

17 votes so far tonight. Lots of buzys.

 

[stevenpensacola]

One of my kids said

"they need to give Taylor some of that medicine that you give us when we can't go to the bathroom...."

 

[RyMickey]

So I couldn't get through for Kat at all for the first half hour...decided to give it a rest. Called back a few minutes ago and got through 4 times...uh oh...there could be trouble...

 

[kathyk2]

I thought Kat's version of Over the Rainbow was amazing> I loved all of Taylor's songs I've tried to get though to Taylor's line without success. I thought Simon would never compliment Taylor I cheered when he finally did.

 

[llij]

I've gotten through about 4 times for Kat. I can't get through at all for Elliott.

 

[gypsydoodlebug]

J-town, Kentucky, get off the phone! I need to vote, too!!

 

[MAKmom]

Is the phone # 1 866 idols 03 for Taylor?

 

[ShannonRT]

One of my kids said

"they need to give Taylor some of that medicine that you give us when we can't go to the bathroom...."

 

[mum4jenn]

Voting must be slowing down now. I have gotten through to Taylor about 12 times now all of those in the last few minutes except the first call that I made it through on in the first couple of minutes. Now I will try some for Kat. Over The Rainbow brought tears to my eyes.

 

[TLHB70]

I want a Taylor vs. Elliott final.
DDs and DH want a Taylor vs. Kat final.

I am dialing non-stop for Elliott on my cell and have gotten through about 5 times.
DD is dialing non-stop for Kat on landline and has only gotten through about 5 times.

 

[J.Cooper]

Is the phone # 1 866 idols 03 for Taylor?

Yep. I can't get thru none of his lines. You can vote for him also at 1-866 Idols 09 and 06.

Good Luck!