American Idol: Season 10 PART III

[damo]

We've all known each other on these boards for a decade. I think we can all continue to get along. I just hope and pray next year is more entertaining with hotter guys. And by guys I mean men, not boys!!!

 

[FINFAN]

And you are mine,too... see even people who don't see eye to eye can like each other!

Robin you betcha! And for what it's worth, we actually agree on more than we disagree, especially if it is Cougarlicous!

 

[FINFAN]

We've all known each other on these boards for a decade. I think we can all continue to get along. I just hope and pray next year is more entertaining with hotter guys. And by guys I mean men, not boys!!!

It HAS been a decade! Yet we're all still 29, lol. Sigh, yes, it does make all the difference in a season doesn't it?

 

[Robinrs]

Robin you betcha! And for what it's worth, we actually agree on more than we disagree, especially if it is Cougarlicous!

Cougar??? I resemble that remark!!!

 

[Nancy]

wow...10 years. :thud:


My thoughts are they need to raise the age limit not lower it. History has shown that a lot of those child stars whether music or other do not handle fame all that well. I know home life plays into it, but in a format like Idol maturity goes a long way.

 

[damo]

wow...10 years. :thud:


My thoughts are they need to raise the age limit not lower it. History has shown that a lot of those child stars whether music or other do not handle fame all that well. I know home life plays into it, but in a format like Idol maturity goes a long way.

I would love to see it raised to 18. And have it only for men.

 

[Nancy]

LOL...if that is the case they need to make it 21.

 

[TLSnell1981]

Now 24,999,999...

24,999,998

Of course I saw it....

Me too.

The sad thing about message boards is that what you intend to say and what is actually perceived can be two different things. There is obviously a reason why you keep getting chosen and singled out.

Ya think?

 

[fairestoneofall]

I'd like to hear why VFTW thinks Scotty is a "goofball." I'm not Scotty's biggest fan but he seems like a decent kid, has manners, isn't full of himself (yet) but seems like a nice young man.

I think the reason why no one got onto James or Daughtry for being shocked at their departure is because most were shocked also. So many people here, on FB and in RL were just waiting for Haley to get gone and wondering why she was still around week after week. That was the difference IMHO. While not everyone I know was a fan of James' everyone believed the young man had talent, for sure.

The night he went home someone said they were afraid he'd "go off" on stage. Maybe people were just glad he went off without any type of bad show.

so, it's okay if they were shocked because people liked them?

i honestly don't think the ending looked like she snubbed Lauren at all. i think a lot is that those who don't like her are going to see what they want to see. i was really ambivalent. i neither disliked her nor was a fan. i don't get attitude from her at all.

 

[TLSnell1981]

but that's ok) is just that, calling her out, Smackdown? If what all the people post about her here is a smackdown, the real world is going to be a shocker, lol. My personal knowledge of her would be just that, personal and not my place to post on a public forum. If you like her,( not sure) I find it strange that you would be posting looking for dirt on her.

Oh my goodness! There are mean girls in th real world, talking trash about Haley? My, my, my...must be a first! Jealous girls bearing their fangs, out for blood. Or, maybe, a $1000 story in the National Enquirer, just like James step-daddy dearest?

 

[fairestoneofall]

i really REALLY hope that next season is better.

AI doesn't produce stars. i think that people like to watch, but of the 20-something million who watch, the winners can't even sell 300k albums? that's pretty sad.

that being said, i'm just ready for something more interesting. i was not an Adam fan, but at least he was interesting to watch. you just didn't know what he was going to do next. i think he was the last really truly interesting contestant they've had.

 

[Mean Queen]

The vitrol is all that's on this thread now. Look at what's left!

When it was Adam and Kris there was so outrageous Kris love, either, just a LOT of Adam SCREAMS posts. Kris won due to the anti Adams, not due to the fact that people truly LOVED him, like David Cook the year before.

This year there is a lot of How sweet and awwwws about the final two, but compare that to the Haley posts.... This thread would die to cricket sounds if they talked only about the Hee Haw twins.

She's GONE people. She cannot pillage your towns or molest your kids now!!

She's a nasty, vile, attitudy female dog... we got it! She snubbed America's Sweetheart.. how DARE she!!! She scoots, hisses and growls and is the worse person EVER!!!!!!




I feel better now....

 

[Mean Queen]

wow...10 years. :thud:


My thoughts are they need to raise the age limit not lower it. History has shown that a lot of those child stars whether music or other do not handle fame all that well. I know home life plays into it, but in a format like Idol maturity goes a long way.

I think so too. I haven't liked the idea of the young kids being subjected to national humiliation

 

[damo]

i really REALLY hope that next season is better.

AI doesn't produce stars. i think that people like to watch, but of the 20-something million who watch, the winners can't even sell 300k albums? that's pretty sad.

that being said, i'm just ready for something more interesting. i was not an Adam fan, but at least he was interesting to watch. you just didn't know what he was going to do next. i think he was the last really truly interesting contestant they've had.

Okay. They have to be over 21. Have to be hot. Have to be guys. Have to be interesting. Anything else we can add to our wish list? Doesn't matter if they sing well, right?

 

[hulagirl87]

I was thinking the same. That stupid goat-boy stuck around and Chris got the boot. Injustice indeed.

That must be why I forgot about him. I honestly don't remember Elliot Yamin being in the final 3! I seriously thought that it was down to Chris, Katherine, and Taylor. wow, sorry Elliot!


I wish that I still had last night's episode so that I could go back and watch it. I would love to see how Hayley snubbed Lauren. It would just give me another reason to dislike her

I guess at this point I don't really care who wins. While I don't care for Scotty, I don't think that either of them will be a top selling artist or anything. Not like a Kelly Clarkson or a Carrie Underwood, that's for sure.

 

[fairestoneofall]

Okay. They have to be over 21. Have to be hot. Have to be guys. Have to be interesting. Anything else we can add to our wish list? Doesn't matter if they sing well, right?

um. have to be straight. i have a hard time drooling otherwise.

 

[damo]

um. have to be straight. i have a hard time drooling otherwise.

We just won't have them tell us til it is over. You'll never even know. Just like Adam Lambert....

 

[damo]

That must be why I forgot about him. I honestly don't remember Elliot Yamin being in the final 3! I seriously thought that it was down to Chris, Katherine, and Taylor. wow, sorry Elliot!


I wish that I still had last night's episode so that I could go back and watch it. I would love to see how Hayley snubbed Lauren. It would just give me another reason to dislike her

I guess at this point I don't really care who wins. While I don't care for Scotty, I don't think that either of them will be a top selling artist or anything. Not like a Kelly Clarkson or a Carrie Underwood, that's for sure.

I posted the video. You might as well join in the fun.

 

[Robinrs]

Okay. They have to be over 21. Have to be hot. Have to be guys. Have to be interesting. Anything else we can add to our wish list? Doesn't matter if they sing well, right?

um. have to be straight. i have a hard time drooling otherwise.

And they have to pick BLACK men who DON'T look like Big Mike, Jacob Lusk or ::barf: Todrick Hall.... There really are some out there, darnit, FIND THEM!!!

 

[Robinrs]

We just won't have them tell us til it is over. You'll never even know. Just like Adam Lambert....

No one has to confess to me, I've got gaydar like a mad dog.