An athletic scholarship doesn't have to be about tearing your body apart.
I would rather know that dd earns one by doing something other than "being pretty". As long as the girl who gets the pagent scholarship doesn't set her whole world on her looks and knows she can accomplish things because of her abilities--good for her and I think the scholarships are great. But some of these little girls on this show, because of these idiot mothers, are going to grow up thinking everything they can do is because of their looks.
Are these band members told that they have to do these things to "look better"? or is it so that they all look the same? And I would have to ask the band director what hair extensions had to do with performing in the band.
For me, its not just what these girls wear. Its the thought process that they NEED flippers because their natural little girl teeth aren't pretty enough. That a 3 year old NEEDS a spray tan. That these children are at these pagents crying in the back because they are tired and they don't want to do this and these "mothers" keep pushing them. At that point it ceases to be something for the child and starts to be for the mother.
All of my kids have stayed involved in something from the time they were very young. And everything was a choice for them, not for me. And at no time would I have ever let someone push dd to do something to change her looks. A little glitter or heavy lipstick so that they shine on stage is one thing. Something that makes a child look years older is completely different. IMHO, there is no reason for pagents that change the way the child looks.
Yes, the band kids are TOLD they need to look a certain way for continuity in the band. These are some of the top bands in the nation, it happens and just because YOU didn't do it doesn't mean it isn't done.
YOu picked trhe absolute worst examples you can find of dance costumes. Those are HORRIBLE. Here are some my DD wore this year. These are what they are SUPPOSED to look like:
http://www.weissmansreadytoship.com/tiny_ballet/4956.aspx
https://curtaincallcostumes.com/products/product-page-t.php?prodid=1693
I don't see much resemblance to pagent dresses. Our studion would NEVER use most of what you showed. TACKY.
Like I have been saying, my problem with pagents is NOT the makeup, dresses ect though I do feel they are too much and not at all like dance costumes. My problem is that it teaches little girls that you have to be pretty and fake to be a winner, or to accepted and like. Dance, at least the way we do it, doesn't do that.
The key word is SOME recitals. Far from all of them do this, in fact , I can only think of one studio locally who pushes that kind of thing. All of them compete but there is only one that uses the over the top costumes.
In my expereince, very few parents in the pagent world can "do it right". The very quickly get caught up in that world and become some version of what you see on TV. Yes, those are the most extreme example, but typically, if you spend any time at all in that world, you end up going there. The only poeple I know wo don't only do 100% natural pagents where no makeup ect is allowed, and there are no glitz dresses.
I don't know of a single competition dance or cheer mom(and I know MANY of them) that tans her DD. ONE cheer gym uses a small hairpiece, and the parents really don't like it so I doubt it will be in the cards next year. For most of those girls, the curls ARE their real hair. You can tell the difference if you know what to look for. We recently watched all star nationals on ESPN, and I only spotted one team with hairpieces. Tanning never even entered my mind so I wasn't looking for that. Several of our local gyms make nationals every year. So no, not everyone that competes on a ntoional level does those things.
I did cologuard in high school and college along with dance. I have NEVER heard of weigh ins or height checks for cologuard. We didn't do tanning, fake hair, or anything other than normal stage makeup. Neither did any squad we played. Dance teams did, but college dance teams are NOT something I want DD involved in. They are way to cutthroat. I watched friends starve themselves and use laxitives to make weight to dance. THAT atmosphere is destructive, but a well run studio that takes kids as threy are is not, and most dance studios that compete are just that. Very few actually exhibit the over the top behavior you are talking about, but those are typically the ones you see, becuase everyone is talking about how over the top they are.
Again, just because YOU didn't do it, doesn't mean it isn't done. Also, you are talking about a local dance studio that does ballet, other posters are talking about competition squads at the regional and national level. Like I said, turn on ESPN for nationals and you will see exactly what we are talking about.