Hi CableKC! I see that Pizarmom told you why she likes BC, I'll tell you why I like YC more:
1st for me a full balcony is my 1st priority & I hate wasting one one my 2 online check in requests on requesting something that's just a given at YC (some will say well you can request as much as you want at call center, but they'll also say the more you you request the more confusing it is for the room scheduler). I love sitting out on the balcony to people watch & read & take in the view. We got a Juliette balcony for 1 night of our BC stay & hated it, we changed rooms.
2nd is transport, YC is the 1st pick up for the buses, so you always get a seat & you get dropped off at the resort 1st after a long park day. When we stayed at BC a lot of the time we had to stand on the ride to the parks. While BC is closer to Epcot, YC is closer to boat launch to Epcot, DHS, boardwalk & swan/dolphin- of course you can walk to any of the places too, but my DH has a bad knee so any little ways to save on walking we do.
3rd I prefer Captains Grille breakfast over Cape Mays (again with a short walk-you can go to either) it is the exact same breakfast buffet & also has a menu to order from also. It's less expensive as no characters, so it's very quiet & you can generally walk up. Were not QS people so the only thing that bothers me about not having the Marketplace is the refillable drink mugs as you can only get drink mugs filled until 11a at Ale & Compass then you need to go to Huricane Hanna's. I think they just need to put in the pop machine at the store in YC & be done with it.
4th SAB yc enterance seems a little closer to YC lobby to me than the SAB bc enterance us to BC lobby. Again a very minimal thing.
The things I like better about BC: the look of the lobby, but it's very busy as people come from all over for Cape May & spill into the lobby to wait to be seated. The ability to refill mugs at Marketplace. That Tenna works there

!
Our next trip is at BC because there was no availability at YC during our stay, so I'm very open to both places, but my preference is YC mainly for full balcony & the transport proximity to the boat & better bus seating!!! You can't go wrong with either, so have a great trip

!