jade1 said:
Disagree. If I could only go one place in the WORLD it would be BWV BW View, that includes the Virgin Islands, Hawaii, the Mountains, you name it.
This is EXACTLY why were weren't wow'd by the view. I'm glad you think the view is great, but its this sort of insistance that things are the "best" that leads to "expectation inflation." And it lead to us walking out onto a balcony thinking "this will be incredible" to immediately saying "what was all the fuss about." Which was disappointing. Had we walked into the room with a more factual, (and we did have facts, I looked at photos) more tempered critique, we'd have been quite pleased.
There are things I enjoy about Disney and the combination of experiences it gives can't be beat, but I've slept in better hotel rooms, gotten better service, eaten better food, played better golf courses and had better views. Not that Disney isn't good. I've had consistantly good rooms, service, food, golf and views. (And it does have the nicest theme parks I've ever been to).
For the Boardwalk view, it was very nice, very predictible (which I think is one of its biggest advantages). I'd like it better if Disney would take the big lighted EPCOT off Spaceship Earth - because I think that is ugly. Fireworks will depend on where you are, our fireworks view (2nd floor over the screen door) was mostly blocked by ESPN, so we only saw high ones. We found that we could hear the noise outside (particularly the games and the boat bell, but also people noise) while our doors were shut, but it was at the background noise level and only fireworks were really disturbing (I'd think you'd be able to hear fireworks all over) - and only disappointing in that I'd heard that "once you shut the doors you don't hear anything." I've had nicer views in my opinion in Germany and Colorado (of mountains, coming from a plains state, mountains amaze me), in Phuket, Thailand (stunning oceans and islands in a room on stilts over the ocean), in San Francisco (Palace of Fine Arts to the Golden Gate Bridge from a beautiful penthouse room up the hill), and at WDW (of the castle, I'd rather be able to walk to Epcot, but I rather look out the window at the castle).