I think that the way my parents did it was just right.... they gave me a set amount about two years before the wedding (actually, before we were even officially engaged) and said..."This is it, you can use it for a wedding, house downpayment, whatever."
It was $5000 (which was a huge sum to me!). I worked out my budget so that I was able to get just what I wanted within the $5000 budget. I pitched in some of my own $$ as needed and there were a few things in the end that my folks wanted me to have (like a limo) that I was willing to forego for the sake of the budget, that they pitched in for. Probably all told I/we spent $6000 for the wedding (in 1992). It was a traditional church wedding in the church where my parents were married, and a sit down plated meal reception at a country club for about 150 people.
I think lots of people think that they want to help and pay for a daughter or son's wedding and they don't think about how much $$ this could actually entail. I think a set amount ahead of time is perfect. It saves lots of heartache and arguing. I had the option to get married by a JP and save the rest of the $$ for a house, if I really wanted. Or to spend it all on a lavish honeymoon. We opted for a nice traditional wedding. I plan to make the same offer to my DD when it is her time to get married. "Here is a set amount of $$. YOu may spend it however you like, but this is it!"
My in-laws paid for a nice rehearsal dinner (which I think was very hard for them, philosophically, as they are much older than my folks and they still think that a $3.00 eggs/toast/coffee meal in a diner is a rip off!). I'm sure that my MIL spent the entire evening mentally calculating how much less it would have cost to prepare those same foods at home. That said, they certainly didn't begrudge us the dinner. It was offered with love and it was a terrific dinner.
DH and I paid for our own honeymoon. It cost about $2000, not including spending $$ for 7 days at CBR at WDW. It was so long ago I cannot remember if we had PH or UPH or what! I know it was a "package" as I have an aunt and uncle who own a
travel agency and they did the arrangements for me. And they discounted me their commission.
That's all.........................P