It was San Angel Inn for me too. We've been thinking about it for the last couple of trips, but the mixed reviews, and a tiny bit of 'fear' of authentic Mexican food, we've been hesitant. All three of us really enjoyed our lunch in September. I had the 3 tacos (substituted the green sauce for the red), my mom had the enchiladas, and my dad had the sirloin and chilaquiles (I figured he'd be ok w/the sirloin, but I was surprised he liked the chilaquiles too). We had a later lunch ADR so it wasn't very crowded, and we lucked out with a seat right by the water. We will definitely be going back!
I was also pleasantly surprised by my lunch at Rose & Crown. I usually get the steak here, but have them leave the sauce off because I usually find that sauces overpower the flavor of the steak. This time I forgot to ask to skip the sauce, and I really enjoyed it. It was not overpowering at all.