I have never been the the Swan or Dolphin. I have been to the All-Star Resorts a few times and being there absolutely SCREAMS Disney. I mean the whole decor of the resort - the pool area, the rooms - has characters all around. But the last time we went (2001) we stayed at the YC. I LOVED it there - but I don't remember there being anything so obviously "Disney" about it except for the character wake-up calls and the Mickey soaps. I found it "magical" because it was a beautiful, luxurious resort right outside of EPCOT and MGM- not really because of the soaps and the calls. I guess what I am trying to ask is what is everyone talking about when they say the S/D doesn't have any magic when being compared to the Yacht Club, Beach Club or Boardwalk?