I'm a member of the having an 11 yr. old boy club!
Mine is asking for a laptop (he means a little netbook), a dock for his ipod, and Star Wars Wii games. He already has a digital camera and phone (not an i-phone, just one with a keyboard). He's also getting the 39 Clues books he doesn't have yet, and he loves those Schliech(sp?) animals -- he has a bunch but I'm sure I'll find a few new ones to put in his stocking.
He already has a Patriots jersey and Celtics shirt, and that's the extent of his sports love. Ok, he likes the Patriots cheerleaders and the Celtics dancers, but Mom's not ready to support that yet....
He's really into Star Wars: Clone Wars, so I'm hoping there might be something he really likes. One of his favorites is a dictionary of all the Star Wars aliens. He can be occupied by that for hours. He also loves the new Dr. Who, so we'll get him some comic books.
I'm also thinking in terms of "experiences" for him -- coupon for a day out with Mom and/or Dad, doing whatever he wants to do. He loves to go to the movies, Science Museum, bowling, etc., (so we're going to go anyway...), it seems like a gift he will appreciate since it's "His Day".
Maria