Our experience at Saratoga Spring in January 2009 invovled an AC unit that had frozen up in 80+ degree weather, front desk staff that actually didn't note the problem on either one of my two phone calls, wet carpet, hair in the showers, credit card confusion on KTTW cards, in the end they had to replace our KTTW cards a total of 5 time - for a party 6! That's 30 KTTW cards over a 7 night stay!
AND this was our very first
DVC stay! So were we questioning becoming members?? I seem to remember doing such!
I have found that Front Desk CM's are not always up to par on correct information, correct procedure, and proper social protocol.
On our most recent trip I over heard a front desk CM revealing some very personal information about a guests financial situation in a not so 'library' voice.
When we checked in at AKV in December 2009, the CM spoke very broken english and had a very had time giving us directions to our room.
In the end - the question we all have to ask ourselves is this -
Have I ever made a mistake at work?
Not a single soul can say that they have NEVER made a mistake at work. It's inevitable - we are all human. We are all going to make mistakes.
I don't know how many of you have ever checked to see how much the average Disney CM makes - but it's isn't much folks! Some people spend more in a week at WDW than some CM's make a YEAR! Most CM's work for minimum wage - or barely above.
It's the Disney Difference that seperates the Disney employee from the local gas station attendant.
The only time I have ever been upset with a Disney CM was about the AC unit at Saratoga. I told the original CM what was wrong - and he swore that housekeeping had just cleaned the carpets - that's why they were wet. It took 5 phone calls to get all that worked out - and finally - around 2am our villa temperature fell below the 80 degree mark. We had a maint. guy in our room for 3+ hours that night! He even worked over so we would have to be disrupted again when the shift change happened.
So at the end of the night - it wasn't the Maint. guy's fault - it was the Front Desk CM who thought he knew more at the Front Desk than I did in the room that was over 90 degrees!
As compensation, we got FastPasses for our party. While not a HUGE thing - it definitely made up for the time we wasted.
I have also dealt with a rather incompetent
Disney Cruise Line Guest Service CM as well - but that's for another time.
At the end of the day - policies are policies - people are people - and we all make mistakes.
I think the OP's compensation was sufficient considering the face value of a 1Day Park Hopper (7 of them!)- and half points returned to your account!
BUT - let's all remember - we all make mistakes - even at work!
AND - let's not forget - we all make mistakes - even at work!
Tread lightly on the CM's - they are just like us - humans - people - who make mistakes..... sometimes even at work!