Hi Sarah.
I guess you may remember me ranting about this on here several times - I got burned by Tarzan, I got burned by A Bug's Life - both of which had a SE come out after the reguar release. I said I wouldn't get burned again. Let's see, dinosaur, eng, toy story, fantasia, they had a SE that came out with the original at the same time. Batb, snow white, sleeping beauty was only the special edition 2-disc. Peter pan and dumbo were SE's but only one disc, so who knows what will happen.
I haven't bought 3 dvds - pinochio, pocohontas and hercules because the release was so bare bones (and in the case of P and H not anthropomorphic) that I figured eventually they would be released again. So I feel that I came out right with Pocohontas.
This will be our fourth version of Mary Poppins on some form of media. I have never opened my Alice in Wonderland dvd; when I heard a month or so ago that the Alice SE would be coming out, I swore an oath that I WOULD be taking this one back to the
disney store and trading it in. And by god I will.
Like you, Lilo and Stitch is the one that especially bugs me because I asked up and down if there would be a 2-disc. All the disney store cast thought that there would ONLY be a 2-disc before it came out. Anyway, we decided at the time to go ahead and buy the L&S dvd, and if a SE came out later it wasn't that much to have spent on it. You will remember the threads on here about that release.
Ultimately though, I am really seeing the positive side of these releases. I really am. It disproves the claim from jhm that there will be no more 2-disc sets. Coupled with the upcoming live action 2-dvds of the witch mt's and apple dumpling gang, and the treasures coming out at the end of the year, and the rumor of the 2-disc darby o'gill for next year, well, I think things are going better for us at bvhe than it seemed a few months ago.
Also, I don't get the deal with packaging. They can't afford inserts for some dvds, but sleeping beauty has a card board outer sleeve with the EXACT same artwork as the dvd cover, front and back. What is the point with that?
One other thing abour releases, I heard a rumor that they are going to package together rescuers and rescuers down under for a special price. So if you don't have those you might want to wait.
Roger Rabbit didn't really count because the first release was through Anchor Bay; I didn't buy that early one because I figured there would be a later release. If you did buy it, hey, you had it for a couple of years before it came out again.
WDWGUIDE, I am going to take a different opinion than yours. I perfer wide of course, but some people really like full screen. I don't know why, but they do. What I don't like is when a company releases two versions - a separate wide screen and full screen version. I think that is bad when they could just put one on one side of the disc and the other on the other. What happens is, a place like blockbuster only orders one version, and you end up with being able to rent only the full screen version of some films (well that has happened here at our block buster, not sure if that is everywhere). I would rather them put both versions in at the same price rather than selling each one as different versions.
What I am still not happy about with bvhe is the discs still are funky in terms of putting them in and starting them up - or programming them to start up. At least you can fast forward through previews and stuff now, but it still is a pain.
I wish that they would find a plan and stick with it for the sake of us collectors.
oh shoot, one more thing
three audio commentaries with director Gore Verbinski and star Johnny Depp, producer Jerry Bruckheimer and stars Keira Knightley and Jack Davenport, and writers Stuart Beattie, Ted Elliot & Terry Rossio and Jay Wolpert, the "An Epic At Sea: The Making of Pirates of the Caribbean" documentary, deleted scenes,a "Moonlight" scene progression, blooper reel, "Below Deck: An Interactive History Of Pirates" notes and a still gallery
I know it is silly, but I was sort of hoping they would put in the Old world of Disney show from the opening of POTC, where the pirates come in on the Columbia and break down the door. Shoot.