DBF and I liked Tony's - we have trouble finding places for us to eat since he is super picky and doesn't really like character meals, so places for TS meals around MK can be problematic. I don't remember specifically what I had for dinner - I think it might have been the eggplant - so I guess that doesn't speak well that it was fairly unemorable, but I do remember we thought that the calamari as an appetizer was very yummy, and the Tiramisu for dessert was really really good!
We also had great service - our waiter was Dirk and he was really great! Very attentive, friendly, gave us plenty of time between courses, always had a full glass. Loved him! We're planning on going back next trip. Hope our experience wasn't just a fluke!