As with everything, the Pirate Night Experience is very subjective. That being said, we've gone to 4 of the parties and looking forward to a 5th. My kids and I do dress up, we enjoy the theming in the dining rooms and we get a kick out of the party. The cruise staff does a great job. Plus, we think it's cool to be at a Pirates party on a ship in the Caribean. The fire works are cool, not what they do in the parks, but pretty impressive for a ship at sea. I also make sure I get a smoked turkey leg!