LandonDunes
Mouseketeer
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2014
- Messages
- 263
Welcome to the DIS!
Personally, I would stick with the GF.
Given that October is a fairly quiet month in WDW (with the exception of F&W), I don't think you have to worry too much about the pool feeling crowded. As of yet, it hasn't really been an issue and the GF has a much larger courtyard pool in addition to the beach pool where most Poly guests would likely be inclined to go with kids. We actually prefer the courtyard pool anyway.
Although many people seem to think of the GF as "stuffy" because of the theme and its being the flagship resort, we have never found this to be the case. If anything, we sometimes feel like there are more kids running around the GF lobby than there are at many other deluxe resorts. We have never encountered any snobby behavior and do not find it different than any other resort in that way. We love sitting in the lobby in the evening listening to the pianist and band play and then walking outside through the beautiful grounds with the view of the castle in the distance.
As for the Contemporary vs. the GF, that just comes down to personal preference. The GF grounds are much nicer than those at the CR and it is also nice to have the ability to walk to the Poly via walkway if you want to spend time at that resort. The GF pools are definitely nicer than the CR pool, which lacks any landscaping and just looks sort of concrete. IMO, the only pluses to the CR over the GF are the slightly bigger rooms, quick monorail stop to the TTC, and the ability to walk to and from MK. If you spring for a tower room, those room views are also pretty impressive. The atrium area of the CR is also fun for kids since the monorail runs through it and Chef Mickey's is very popular, etc. As convenient as the CR location is, though, we keep finding ourselves returning to the Poly and GF because the resort grounds and ambiance just feel so much nicer and secluded. That being said, the CR has many fans and it really just comes down to which theme appeals to you most.
Have a great trip wherever you end up!![]()
Wow! Thank you so much for the insight. I feel much better about sticking with the GF. Very nice of you to take the time.