May I ask what ship you will be on and the ages of your children?
My youngest had to be dragged out of the kids club. My oldest is more shy and we have had mixed results, but I believe that is more owing to his social awkwardness than the clubs.
But as a mom I find cruising the most relaxing and least stressful of any vacation. Not just because of the kids clubs, but overall I get real time off from all the daily decisions and mundane responsibilities and focus on fun.
Thank you for your response. I will have a 14yo, 10yo and 4yo. The older two are relatively socially awkward and so freeplay/hanging out and meeting and bonding with new people within that context has never been easy for them. They are girls and do not like video games at all. I'm not faulting Disney for the fact that my kids need structure and guidance to have fun in that setting. I'm just bummed that it quite possibly might not be a great fit for them. Oh well - it's probably good to keep my expectations reasonable. We have 2 cruises booked on the Magic.
I am still encouraged that it will still be a break for me, if not a break from parenting for an couple hours here and there. Like at Disney parks, it's a break for me when my kids are entertained and engaged - even when I'm right next to them. I'm sure it will still be great family fun!