pinkxray
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Sep 4, 2009
- Messages
- 5,349
Wow! A new ticker!! How awesome!!
My choices?? Value AOA no question!
Mod would be POR/POFQ because that is our fave!!
Deluxe: 1st: AK, nd WL and 3rd BW during Christmas (I would rank differently at other times of the year!)
I think you are the first person to list AKL as your first choice for deluxe. I think that is my first choice out of all of them, but I think it might be a bit over budget this trip. Plus, it makes no sense to stay so far away from everything, but I really really want to stay there.
AAH! Such a hard decision. I would LOVE to stay at CSR sometime. I know that Jen stayed there, but wasn't she sick that night? A re-do may be in order. That being said, the southwest isn't the most Christmassy. Trust me. I live here. No amount of Christmas trees will make me feel as though it is Christmas, and I have lived here my entire life!
I like AoA, but I refuse to support Little Mermaid anything. Ariel is awful.
POR is great because you would have the extra bed. If you choose somewhere besides POR, I force Jen make the resort selection and then say, "well, this was your choice so you have to sleep with Caitlin."

I really wish they had spread the standard rooms throughout AOA so you could stay in a different section without getting the family suite. I would love to stay in the Lion King section but I'm not paying for the suite that I don't really need.
Alright let's see... and before I begin, take my opinion with a grain of salt as I've only ever stayed at Pop and am speaking not from experience, but from what I would want to do!
Ok so you might be able to tell from my own upcoming trip that I am all for this option. All the reviews coming in on it are amazing, the Big Blue Pool looks pretty awesome despite the lack of water slide or hot tub (assuming you get pool time and weather). The LM rooms look adorable for an all-girl trip. Also it's new and fun. If I only had 4 days I know I'd be spending them all in the parks and therefore unlikely to want to spend much on the hotel (and here you should keep in mind that I'm very cheap!) This would be my first choice among values of course, but it would also be my first choice among all your choices.
Hmm, I think I'd have to go with POFQ since no one has stayed there, especially if your DH never wants to. Although the appeal of an extra bed in an AB room at POR is quite a draw. Personally I'd axe CSR, agreeing with oboedm (but without her firsthand knowledge!) that the southwest isn't someplace I'd jump to call Christmassy. So in order of my preference:
1. POFQ
2. POR
3. CSR
Alright, some thoughts.
ALK - I have to admit to putting myself in each situation and thinking about it as if it were me going, and I wouldn't go to AKL without my DH. I know how much he would adore the place and just couldn't do it without him. So I guess I have to sympathize with you when you wonder about Jen's wanting to do it without her DH. I wouldn't. Also as much as I want to stay at AKL (seriously, it's #1 on my list of somedays!) I just couldn't justify it for a quick trip. I'd have to spend more time at the resort to really enjoy it. But it would be awfully pretty at Christmas time...
WL - If not for Jen having seen it, this would be my top choice for a deluxe. Very Christmassy and as the cheapest, it would be my pick for a short trip.
GF - I have to agree with your DH, I don't much like that place. I have to put it last on my Deluxe list. Also, too expensive.
Boardwalk - My top choice. The ability to walk to two parks would be a bonus on a short trip and I think the Boardwalk is beautiful anyway, and would be stunning at Christmas!
In order of my preference:
1. Boardwalk
2. Wilderness Lodge
3. Animal Kingdom Lodge
4. Grand Floridian
Whoops! I've written a novel! Rainy weekday mornings make me want to talk Disney more I guess!
Thanks for all of your input! I'm glad it was a rainy morning b/c I love hearing other opinions. I really think we might end up at AOA. The three of us all seem to want to try it out, so why not save money if we can?
I think my top choice overall would be AKL and it is also Caitlin's top choice. But I would feel bad that since I know Brandon wants to stay there plus John actually likes it there.
My vote is for Wilderness Lodge.. I just think that would be a perfect place for Christmas feelings!![]()
I always thought I would want to stay at WL if we went in Dec. If we hadn't stayed at VWL last year, it would probably still be my #1 choice.