Don't know when you trip is, but keep in mind that Gasparilla Grill and Games is expected to close August 24, and reopen in December.
Of all of the MK resort CS places, I'd say Captain Cooks is my favorite, especially for atmosphere, windows to look out and see the tropical foliage, and tables to sit out there if you wish. All of these things we've eaten there have been good: Hawaiian Flatbread, Aloha Pork Sandwich, Pork Nachos, Multigrain Turkey Club, Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Stir-Fried Noodles.
We've liked the food at Gasparilla's too, but the indoor seating area was cramped and noisy with the games in the same space, but that might change with the re-do. Again, you could take your food to tables right outside the door if the weather was nice.
Contempo: I've only eaten there once, they had some interesting food offerings though.
Roaring Forks - the Lodge is big and beautiful, but the CS is rather cramped and the offerings seem more limited, which might be because I don't find much on the menu I personally like... but that is just me!