Membership Magic Beyond

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am confused...where does it say non US citizens purchase this. I never read that.
other than that not sure why people are either happy or sad about this. It's a way for money mouse to make money. Some will buy some wont
 
I won’t pay it because I don’t think room requests should be allowed even for free, but I am not getting angry if they decide to offer it to others who are willing to pay, especially since I have to deal with it now when I disagree it should be allowed. First available is what I wish they did and never allowed requests at all.

You aren't angry if your thousands of dollars investment relegates you to a dumpster view because some peon in the executive office decided to make room views pay to play after the fact so they can try to save their stock price?

I think you are very knowledgeable with the things you share on here and you do a great job keeping things maintained on a public forum, but your view of being a customer and what that should mean to a company has always baffled me. While I don't expect everything from a company, there's a very fine lime which Disney as a whole has crossed recently and people are leaving them in droves.
 
I am confused...where does it say non US citizens purchase this. I never read that.
other than that not sure why people are either happy or sad about this. It's a way for money mouse to make money. Some will buy some wont
In the FAQ for the program on the DVC site, under the Who is Eligible question:

The Membership Magic Beyond option is available for purchase to Disney Vacation Club Members (DVC-Y) with eligible ownership interests currently in good standing, who are U.S. residents. Corporate Memberships are ineligible. To learn more about Membership Extras, including eligibility, Members should see the Membership Extras Acknowledgment and Disclosure Statement. The 2025 Membership Magic Beyond Option Terms and Conditions apply.
 

You aren't angry if your thousands of dollars investment relegates you to a dumpster view because some peon in the executive office decided to make room views pay to play after the fact so they can try to save their stock price?

I think you are very knowledgeable with the things you share on here and you do a great job keeping things maintained on a public forum, but your view of being a customer and what that should mean to a company has always baffled me. While I don't expect everything from a company, there's a very fine lime which Disney as a whole has crossed recently and people are leaving them in droves.
What’s actually baffling is that you feel like it’s acceptable to personally come for someone who doesn’t have the same experiences or beliefs as you, especially based on some exaggerated hypothetical. There’s plenty of space for debate and @Sandisw has always been respectful of allowing other people to have their opinions without questioning their character.

For those truly upset by this (not international guest, y’all really are getting the short of end of the stick. I’ll be sure to let guest satisfaction know about the unfairness when I can), there are many better ways to direct your time and effort to facilitating change, then making people on here who haven’t had your specific experiences, maybe newer members, maybe just luckier ones, feel bad for still liking this product or not being mad at this small, if-controversial, decision.

Call your guides, email guest satisfaction, go to the board associations and bring this up with the people who make these calls. If I were as upset with the direction that Disney and DVC has been going for as long as some of you have been, I’m not sure I’d still even be a member. Why are you still giving them your money? There are a lot of grievances and you’re more than entitled to them. But your actions in other places will be louder than your words here on Disboards.
 
Last edited:
I am confused...where does it say non US citizens purchase this. I never read that.
other than that not sure why people are either happy or sad about this. It's a way for money mouse to make money. Some will buy some wont
It’s the beginning of the end of free extras, you will eventually be mad too it will just take longer

Also, T&C’s say US only, like a lot of things DVC does e.g Magical Beginnings, competitions, referrals etc etc
 
You aren't angry if your thousands of dollars investment relegates you to a dumpster view because some peon in the executive office decided to make room views pay to play after the fact so they can try to save their stock price?

I think you are very knowledgeable with the things you share on here and you do a great job keeping things maintained on a public forum, but your view of being a customer and what that should mean to a company has always baffled me. While I don't expect everything from a company, there's a very fine lime which Disney as a whole has crossed recently and people are leaving them in droves.

And, I know there are people who no longer support Disney to the degree they did and my DH is one of them…he is not a fan of all the changes so he doesn’t go as much as he used to.


But, if we are talking views, I have had the dumpster view at BRV and it wasn’t enough to ruin my trip. I have overlooked the roof at RIV and VGF again, not enough to ruin my trip.

So if I am stuck with what someone else might think is a horrible view because someone else paid for a better view because views are that important to them to have it, then I am willing to be stuck, even if yes, it benefits a stock holder.

It comes back to seeing things from the lense of a consumer who gets to make decisions when a business makes changes. I am a huge believer in choice too and that we get to make our own choices, regardless of what others believe and think.

Maybe most consumers don’t do things this way…but I do.

Heck, I drive a Dodge truck now because my Chevy dealership wasn’t willing to help me as a long time customer because of new owners. Was I mad because they refused to give me fair value for my trade, without paying them extra? Nope because I got to choose and they ended up losing in the end.

So, Disney is a business and if they make decisions that hurt their bottom line, they will adjust or suffer the consequences.

But I still believe that more choices are always better for consumers and as long as someone is informed ahead of time and know upfront what changes will be, then choices are a good thing

Bringing it back to this particular program, for me, as a consumer, it’s a good deal and I appreciate DVC creating something that allows me to use my membership in a way will save me money, as long I choose to buy it.

ETA: Anyone who doesn’t like aspects of the program can and should let DVC know…but I also think it’s okay that some of us don’t see this particular program as a money grab.
 
Last edited:
It’s the beginning of the end of free extras, you will eventually be mad too it will just take longer

Also, T&C’s say US only, like a lot of things DVC does e.g Magical Beginnings, competitions, referrals etc etc
Those things you referenced are regulated differently than what's offered in this first iteration of the package. There is nothing in there that we, as Canadians, cannot access today (from a product perspective, at full/normal value, or with current DVC discounts on things like APs and party tix), except the waitlist for the lounges. We even attended some of those DVC character greetings they ran this summer and they were pretty nice. Now we'd be shut out of those too.

So that is why this is a departure that separates non-US DVC owners in a different manner than ever before. If this is the future, then it will negatively impact this segment of DVC owners, because things like skip the line and any future similar things can literally put us at the back of the line, with no option to change that (i.e. second class DVC). Contests, referrals etc. don't affect the day-to-day use of the membership and I understand the legalities of those.

For the points I've raised, I don't currently see or understand any legalities driving this, so I've inquired to understand what is driving the difference here. We'll see what DVD/DVC says as to the reasons why.
 
Because its not an opinion question. It's quantifiable that people are losing something to those who pay for privilege. Ditto the special events that will close the lounge.

Ask yourself - will Disney ever offer another ticket "discount" to DVC members who don't pay to be part of the club within the club?


What is the point of charging people to get a discount As opposed to.offering it to all members?


You can feel it doesn't affect someone a lot, but you can't argue that it doesn't affect every single person who doesn't pay.

We have all already paid to be part of the club that now looks like a bunch of used car salesman.

Look as Disney as a whole and the absurd level of upcharges we are at now in every facet of the company. And not just upcharges, but obscene upcharges.

Heck, D23 is now multiple levels of pay wall with even worse execution. That is literally the pathway we are just starting down.

DVC seemed to be somewhat insulated from that until now. Hell, arguably DVC and something like Moonlight Magic (which has progressively gotten worse) were one of the old magical Disney things that still existed. Now comes the pay wall to basically kill that off over time.

It used to be special to be part of DVC. It used to be sold as more than just a room. It is getting to the point where it is now just a room. And a watered down resort experience in many cases. Thank you for your $20k and 50 years of maintenance fees.
I see confusion. Don't forget you just bought a room.

And, I see further confusion: don't forget you just bought a park entrance ticket, not a VIP experience for up to 10 people with a CM in plaid leading you to the front of any line.
There are two conversations going on here. Is this package worth it for people who want it? Is this package acceptable to people who don’t want it? This isn’t an innocuous package where it doesn’t hurt people who don’t want it. It does. Worth it is a subjective question, but does it take away something is objectively true. It does. Period. You may be ok with what it takes away or think it isn’t a big deal, but that doesn’t change the fact that it does.
It's worth it to me and I can afford to buy it. That's what I will do.
For those outraged that DVC is creating DVC-Y class warfare over the MMB offering, should regular ticket holders or the folks staying at value or moderate resorts be selectively outraged over the new Lightening Lane Premier Pass? https://www.wdwinfo.com/walt-disney-world/disneys-new-lightning-lane-premier-pass-isnt-that-bad/

The principle is the same as the discussion here. When the elites staying at a deluxe or DVC resort buy this new LLPP, the experience of other guests is degraded.
Absolutely degraded, because your entrance ticket just allows you in the park and the ability to stand in line if you don't pay extra to jump ahead. You have to pay for the upgraded room and the upgraded experience. I love to go to Animal Kingdom, ride the safari, maybe see the Lion King Show, watch the bird show and walk through the Gorilla and Tiger exhibits, plus I like to go to Conservation Station and do the drawing thing. (I'm old now and no longer into any swirly rides.) Used to be able to do most of that and be out by lunch time. Not anymore. No ten minute walk on for the Safari and finish in about 35 minutes. The last three times it's been an hour and a half. Tempting to pay for it but I've begrudged myself the ability and stuck to the slow as cold molasses line and entertained myself by talking to my fellow line waiters. And I've learned to carry water and a couple of snacks. People sort of come out of their shells if they are stuck with you for that long. Sometimes I learn stuff and make some temporary friends.
Yes, it makes someone have to wait longer who doesn’t pay when it’s crowded.

It is definitely a change to the program and if I wasn’t clear that it is, then yes, it is.

But isn’t that change coming with benefits we don’t already have? Isn’t that really the discussion?

Is the introduction of a priority waitlist for lounges worth accepting in exchange for the other tangible benefits we are getting for a fee?

Some will say yes and some will say no. And, that, as you say, is subjective.

Every decision DVC makes impacts owners. It’s just that not every owner will see them the same way…
I think some people on here (not you) don't remember what's actually enforceable in the DVC contract, and are hung up on possible freebies which have existed since conception of the program in one way or another and have come and gone.
I’ll go one further and say that LLPP shouldn’t exist for anyone. It’s not ok that it exists for deluxe and not moderate, it’s not ok that it exists at all. In my own personal opinion of course. I didn’t like Genie+ either. I also don’t like how they limited DAS to only certain disabilities that are the most faked. Want to open all the cans of worms?
In one sense I agree with your sense of fairness but in real life it's not a realistic focus to have. You may see yourself continuously disappointed that something you once loved (maybe) is changing and not in a way that you want to accept.
If nobody buys this, then the "priority" lounge access is meaningless. So let's all stand firm and refuse to buy it. I don't see any value here at all, frankly.
No. I'll be in line to buy it, 'this' time. Maybe not all the time as stuff has a way of changing, disappearing, pricing people out, etc. In my mind, nobody should have bought Riviera with the restrictions. I didn't. But I've stayed there several times now with my unrestricted points. I think it's a lovely resort but I won't ever need to buy it.
You aren't angry if your thousands of dollars investment relegates you to a dumpster view because some peon in the executive office decided to make room views pay to play after the fact so they can try to save their stock price?

I think you are very knowledgeable with the things you share on here and you do a great job keeping things maintained on a public forum, but your view of being a customer and what that should mean to a company has always baffled me. While I don't expect everything from a company, there's a very fine lime which Disney as a whole has crossed recently and people are leaving them in droves.
I've had the dumpster view at BRV. View wasn't terrible or that disturbing but it was a long walk to get there. I'm always the target for the leftover handicapped accessible rooms, but I've avoided sometimes by requesting a far from the elevator room.
It’s the beginning of the end of free extras, you will eventually be mad too it will just take longer

Also, T&C’s say US only, like a lot of things DVC does e.g Magical Beginnings, competitions, referrals etc etc
I've been a little bit mad when something I enjoyed got tanked. You get over it and move forward or you talk with your wallet and move on.
But, if we are talking views, I have had the dumpster view at BRV and it wasn’t enough to ruin my trip. I have overlooked the roof at RIV and VGF again, not enough to ruin my trip.
Me also for BRV. VGF resort studio standard view - last trip - view wasn't horrible, it was nice green grass. In the distance there was a sliver of water visable between buildings so I zoomed in and took that picture and posted it as a 'great view', with another shot of reality following it. My little joke. Plus with my grandchildren the action was in the room and at the pools.

Contract is the only thing remotely enforceable or worth complaining about or taking action on if not followed.
 
The principle is the same as the discussion here. When the elites staying at a deluxe or DVC resort buy this new LLPP, the experience of other guests is degraded.
There is literally zero chance anyone buying the LLPP wasn't already going to purchase standard Lightning Lane access for multiple rides. If you have $450 to shell out on a Premier Pass, you were already loading up on Lightning Lanes for any attraction worth purchasing one for anyway. Also, yes, they don't have preset return times, but they also are limited to one use per attraction, so they aren't increasing rider loads. Guest A is still only riding 7DMT once, whether he rides it at a prescribed time, or on his own schedule.
 
There is literally zero chance anyone buying the LLPP wasn't already going to purchase standard Lightning Lane access for multiple rides. If you have $450 to shell out on a Premier Pass, you were already loading up on Lightning Lanes for any attraction worth purchasing one for anyway. Also, yes, they don't have preset return times, but they also are limited to one use per attraction, so they aren't increasing rider loads. Guest A is still only riding 7DMT once, whether he rides it at a prescribed time, or on his own schedule.
Yes, I know.
 
There is literally zero chance anyone buying the LLPP wasn't already going to purchase standard Lightning Lane access for multiple rides. If you have $450 to shell out on a Premier Pass, you were already loading up on Lightning Lanes for any attraction worth purchasing one for anyway. Also, yes, they don't have preset return times, but they also are limited to one use per attraction, so they aren't increasing rider loads. Guest A is still only riding 7DMT once, whether he rides it at a prescribed time, or on his own schedule.

There is a question on how this will affect regular LL availability knowing that it should in theory eliminate 1 space for every ride ride rather than the 4 or 5 that someone can typically pull up on their phone.
 
Since I’m international too, which email address did you write to?
Yes -- the more the better :)

I sent it originally to an email, and then that kicked back with an email that said to submit this by logging in to the member site, go to contact and fill in the form that way. So I resubmitted it to them that way (it makes sense as it's authenticated with your member # etc.).

Official text they sent is:

For this and all future requests or inquiries sent via email, you will need to log into your account online at DisneyVacationClub.com and follow the process noted below.

Once logged in, hover your cursor over the “Help & Contact” tab and click “Email Us” from the drop down list to submit your inquiry. This will ensure your verification details are securely handled and your request is processed in a timely manner.
 
The debundling of services and perks has been a gradual and consistent change for better part of 2000s, where the price of anything slowly becomes simply just that and nothing else.

The most visible are travel industry with the airlines being the primary drivers of decoupling. Meals, drinks, Checked bags, assigned seats, boarding, checkin, weight limits. Even bathrooms were attempted.

Same for theme parks and hotels.

Dvc is no different, and no surprised. Frankly shocked they keep free parking and laundry.
 
It’s the beginning of the end of free extras, you will eventually be mad too it will just take longer

Also, T&C’s say US only, like a lot of things DVC does e.g Magical Beginnings, competitions, referrals etc etc
AHhh....i did not think of that. You may be correct in which case this stinks. I dislike disney when they make the cash grubs
 
The parking lots are maintained by member dues and so are the laundry facilities, both the ones in the 1+ bedroom villas and the community laundry rooms. So they can't charge extra for them - we're already paying for them.
Ah, so that's why not charged yet! Makes sense.
 
Ah, so that's why not charged yet! Makes sense.
“Not charged yet” and “cannot be charged.” Or maybe I should say they can’t be charged separately. During the few years that Disney charged for resort parking, they couldn’t charge DVC members to park at DVC resorts when staying on points, because we’re already paying.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.















DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top