I'm not sure how to respond to this.
You do realize I was saying that John McCain has good judgment. My point is that you would have to look at places other than McCain's POW experience to find definitive examples of this good judgement.
The point of my post was to argue that McCain's time as a POW can tell you some things you need to know about McCain, but it can't tell you everything you need to know. The things McCains POW experiences can tell you are impressive. The things McCain's non-POW experiences can tell you are also impressive.
Together they add up to lots of reasons to vote for the man.
But maybe this isn't why you wrote your post. Maybe you understood what I was getting at, but since I mentioned that McCain had good judgement you used this as an excuse to bring up Obama's bad judgement.
I should probably bring up that my contention that McCain shows good judgement does not mean he has shown good judgement in every single decision and choice he has ever made. I would apply the same standard to Obama.
Obama chose to offer political support for Kwame Kilpatrick. Because of the actions that happened later, support for Kilpatrick didn't look like such a good idea. But its good to see that once all the evidence came out about Kilpatrick, Obama asked for his resignation. I think that shows good judgement.
Here's an interesting parallel. Among other things, Kilpatrick was convicted of Obstruction of Justice. If you remember,
Scooter Libby was also convicted of Obstruction of Justice. But after Kilpatrick was convicted, Obama dropped all support for him. But after Libby was convicted and then appealed, many felt that McCain showed lukewarm support for Bush's pardon. Both Kwame Kilpatrick and Scooter Libby were convicted of Obstruction of Justice, yet Obama was willing to remove his support while McCain seemed to equivocate whether he would drop his support for Libby.
But this is a one time thing. Even if I was to think that McCain showed poor judgement in this one decision, overall I think McCain has shown excellent judgement.